I agree that list is a bit weird, and very biassed in favour of BB3. I think there may have been some sort of conspiracy at C4 to make people think BB3 was good, so that they can bring on more of the same and worse for BB5.
I've just re-read that though and it sounds really paranoid!!
I didn't actually watch the show at 11:05 on C4 last night and forgot to tape it as well, so at least I didn't have to watch loads of Jade - yuk!