Quote:
Originally Posted by Josy
Zee I honestly think if she was a worst case scenario type of person then there is no way at all she would have left her children in that apartment by themselves, she would know of the dangers of leaving them alone like that.
Running to the restaurant and shouting they have taken her is a really odd thing to do imo even if she was in shock.
|
Yeah, "They've taken her" is very odd. "She's gone" or "I can't find Maddie" or something. The phrasing is weird.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Zee
I think my first thought would be that she'd been kidnapped, if the window was open, though...
|
True. If the window was closed with a shutter down, I wouldn't presume my 3 year old had forced her way out of it.
Quote:
Originally Posted by Cherie
But the later sighting of someone carrying a child would put Gerry having dinner with his friends wouldn't it  |
What do you mean?
I think the guy seen walking towards the beach with a kid was spotted after 10pm IIRC? So between the time Kate found Maddie gone and the police arriving.
But of course at this point, as James points out, their 5 other friends would have been with them at the apartments checking their own kids, helping look around for Maddie. If Gerry disappeared on foot with her they'd have noticed and therefore would have to be lying to cover for him, which takes the theory even further into absurdity.