I probably don't have the authority to talk about this, but I watched DOI for the first time tonight, and can't see why everyone's saying Emily's so bad?
I preferred her routine to Duncans, personally - I was suprised when it was a clean sweep for him, although looks like you were expecting it!
Looks like I'm a bit of a loner with this view though! As I say, only just switched on tonight, so haven't seen any past performances.