I know what you mean James, but I still think if I had to chose between the two it would definitely be Big Brother.
Survivor has never interested me particularly and I'm one of these people who, when they go on holiday, never like camping - I'm only happy staying somewhere civilised and indoors

Call me a wimp, I don't care.
Also I have to admit that I can't swim so if this series of Survivor is anything to go by I'd never even be able to get to the island, let alone participate in some of the challenges.
One of those sun-loungers next to that new pool looks far more appealing to me.