I'll wait to reserve judgement on BOTB but I like the sound of it and I thought the MVP twist was actually quite good
The only problem with it was the fact you could be MVP two weeks in a row, that Elissa was there so she was always going to get it (as amazing as she was) and that they started letting America have it just because they wanted Aaryn/Amanda out which never even worked out anyway. Aside from that I thought it was a decent enough idea