[Shaun]

Despite her pedantry, Mel. The comments @ Fleur using backing vocals, Jake being ill were pedantic but she gave fair comments to Only the Young (too cheesy), Stereo Kicks (too noisy).

Cheryl lost her temper too quickly and just does that dumbfounded "um how dare you speak whilst i'm speaking" look that eats up too much time and as a result she never finishes a sentence. Her points about Stereo Kicks not harmonising were valid but then she got bogged down in the silly 1D/hysteria comparison.

Simon was generally Simon and thought he was funnier than he was and hyped up his crap acts, but was accurate re: Steph being boring, Jack being weaker and Jake's vocals being, at times, terrible.

And Louis used 'you remind me of a young ______' three times tonight, and unnecessarily took cheap shots at Simon's appearance and Cheryl's dress, so he's improving.