[Jamesy]

They're both as bad as eachother really. I suppose it depends how much you support the people involved in both twists. If a good HM won the pass to the final (Ashleigh as one example) the majority of people would have been happy, if a crap HM (Jack for example) was evicted the majority of people would be happy.

In one case a horrible woman won the pass, and the other case an annoying, but potentially entertaining man got evicted. So that's the only reason I believe neither are 'worse' twists. They are both good twists, just with strange outcomes.