Quote:
Originally Posted by Niamh.
I posted this theory I found online on the first page, but it kind of addresses some of those questions you had
Theory #1: Scott Tadych (Avery’s brother-in-law) and Bobby Dassey (Avery’s nephew and Brendan Dassey’s brother) killed Halbach (purposefully or accidentally) and framed Avery for the crime … and then sat back and watched as the Manitowoc County Sheriff’s Department separately did the same.
Evidence: The amount of evidence found on the Avery property — including Halbach’s remains and her car – has led many to surmise that if Steven Avery and Brendan Dassey are innocent, the real killer would still likely be someone who had similar access and opportunity, both to Halbach herself and the Avery property. A number of other Avery family members also lived on the property at the time, including Tadych, Janda and all four of the Dassey boys. It was Janda’s car that Halbach came to photograph for Auto Trader magazine, and Tadych more than likely was privy to her visit. Bobby Dassey testified to seeing Halbach taking pictures of his mother’s car, and both men had access to the various locations where evidence was found. Neither was fingerprinted or submitted DNA, and the trailer where they lived was not searched, so there’s no way of knowing if there was evidence linking them to Halbach’s murder, because they were not investigated.
Other Evidence: Bobby is believed to be Tadych’s accomplice in this theory, based on the fact that the pair conveniently alibi each other for the time of the murder. Both claimed to have gone hunting that afternoon/evening, but not together, and said they passed each other on the highway during the window of time Halbach is believed to have been killed – but there are no other witnesses to offer further corroboration.
Tadych, meanwhile, has a long history of being violent towards women, and showed a strange level of enthusiasm for his brother-in-law’s conviction (he called it “the best thing in the world ever”) despite knowing his step son, Brendan, was facing similar charges. Meanwhile, Bobby Dassey’s testimony at trial had notable inconsistencies and misleading statements, and an unrelated examination the same week as the murder reportedly revealed that Bobby had scratches on his back. Additionally, shortly after Halbach’s death, a coworker of Tadych’s claimed that he was trying to sell a .22 rifle, the same as the gun believed to be the murder weapon, which he said belonged “to one of the Dassey boys.”
__________________
|
...do we know Scott Tadych from the documentary and facts about him, I don't recall any or this is online research..?...that's something that I'll look at as well when I've finished it because although I hadn't figured Scott, I did think straight away last night, Bobby....there is so much incriminating in the prosecution using his testimony...(which the defence had not even been made aware of..)...and it goes with the 'last to see her alive' thing of him also being one of the last people and knowing that he could say something to incriminate Avery and cast all eyes away from him, so a 'perfect crime'..?...also, he went off at 2.45pm-ish, he was sure of time because of his plan to go hunting..?...but could have waited for Teresa to drive off and then in some way, either hijacked her car or followed it and killed her/planted evidence at different times as and when he could and so building it all...also with the messages etc that had been erased and the points that these things are often done by the people closest to the victim and that should have been investigated on as well...?...well, as well as 'close to the victim' suspects, it's surely the same with close to the suspect, those would be the immediate suspects to me/within the family..and who more so than a family member who has suddenly come from nowhere... as observing Teresa going to Avery's van and a huge incrimination and contradiction to Avery's statement....