I love Tiffany Pollard don't get me wrong, she makes my Top 10, but I don't think she's THAT good that she ranks #1 in my Top 20 and is my favourite ever CBB HM. I personally thought there were a few housemates who were better housemates than she was. I wonder if the fact that she was most people's dream CBB HM so her finally going in sorta adds to it in a way and makes people love her even more - quite similar to Janice Dickinson. But I didn't know her prior to CBB (I knew her by name but haven't seen FOL) so maybe if I had, I'd understand, idk
I guess it's down to personal preference at the end of the day. For me, I prefer John McCririck and Luisa Zissman and thought they were better.