[James]

I saw it today, and enjoyed it. I felt I was getting into the story, and caring about the characters (which is what it is all about for me), about half way through.

Spoiler:

There's one moment where they are definitely giving the fans what they want, haha. You'll know what it is when you see it.

Though I thought later it doesn't really fit in with what we see in some of the other films.

Spoiler:

Another thing is there is a lot of bits in the trailers which aren't in the films. In fact I watched an Rogue One advert on Youtube after I saw the film, and it had something which isn't in the film.

Spoiler:

I liked the droid's humour, and the blind martial-arts man, and the phrase he repeated at one stage resonated with me, for some reason.

^Minor spoilers.^.

Bigger spoiler points.

Spoiler:

I think the over-thought themselves trying to explain the flaw in the Death Star. If you were going to build in a exploitable flaw, why make it so difficult to hit (the exhaust port).

Spoiler:

The cgi-ing of one character's face looked a bit 'uncanny valley' - like a video game character. I didn't mind the other one though.