[Jack_]

Sindy is not an All Star, at the very least Sarah, Brittnee and Godfrey are being invited back over her and I'd say at least one of Bruno/Kevin/Naeha/Jordan would get called first too

It's like I loved Arlie, but Sabrina who I couldn't stand is - objectively speaking - far more likely to get cast for an All Stars than he is. Neda, Jon, Sabs, Ika and then either Adel/Heather would probably take priority. With every season that goes by, your chances of getting picked for AS diminishes so someone like Sindy is not production's first or second choice by any means