She is pretty useless. His question is crap, far too black and white, but it's not like it's hard to get around that?
The "fair" policy on illegal immigrants and whether or not they should "be kicked out" is "it depends on their circumstances". If they are purely economic migrants here illegally then yes they should be deported, if they have more complicated circumstances that mean being deported would directly endanger them then their situation should be examined. Simple stuff, surely. Posing a question on binary terms as he is, and trying to force your opponent to "pick one", is a tactic designed to misrespresent the views of the person being asked. But she doesn't have to answer his question on his terms... it sort of seems like she's dancing around because she thinks she HAS to respond to the binary question, when all she actually has to do is offer a third answer.