[Denver]

Reports are saying that the Its a Sin star is in advanced negotiations with the BBC to replace Jodie Whittaker and an announcement is expected soon

[Smithy]

The press never get it right with Dr Who actors

[arista]

Originally Posted by Denver

Reports are saying that the Its a Sin star is in advanced negotiations with the BBC to replace Jodie Whittaker and an announcement is expected soon

too young

[Marsh.]

Olly Alexander fans have discussed wanting him as the next doctor and now it's become a "rumour".

It's a non story.

[Liam-]

Russel Tovey or nobody

[Strictly Jake]

Please no. Can the doctor not just regenerate back into David Tennant. I'd like that sort of level actor/fame

[Tony Montana]

Originally Posted by Strictly Jake

Please no. Can the doctor not just regenerate back into David Tennant. I'd like that sort of level actor/fame

Him or Christopher Eccleston. He was incredible despite his limited appearance.

[Crimson Dynamo]

doctor who jumped the shark about 10 years ago

[Oliver_W]

Yeah anytime the press report that someone is in negotiations or whatever for the role, you can be sure he or she won't get it.

However he'd be a good choice just for the moaning some people would be triggered because he's a white male, others would be upset because he's gay. Both types of toxic fans deserve to be annoyed.

[Crimson Dynamo]

says hi

[Livia]

Presumably they'll lose a similar percentage of watchers as when they turned the Doctor in to a woman. Crack on, BBC...

[bots]

it really doesnt matter who the actors are on Dr Who. The writing is so bad, it's unwatchable. They should get their priorities right

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

it really doesnt matter who the actors are on Dr Who. The writing is so bad, it's unwatchable. They should get their priorities right

This.
The ratings haven't dropped because Jodie is a woman, they wouldn't drop because the actor was gay. They've dropped because it's badly written.

[Livia]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

it really doesnt matter who the actors are on Dr Who. The writing is so bad, it's unwatchable. They should get their priorities right

I've got to agree with this. It's felt lately like every story is a chance for them to make some preachy statement to educate us all. Bored with it...

[Jake.]

Originally Posted by Livia

Presumably they'll lose a similar percentage of watchers as when they turned the Doctor in to a woman. Crack on, BBC...

What point are you trying to make, exactly? That the Doctor shouldn’t be played by a gay actor?

[Tom4784]

Deleted Post

[Saph]

I've not watched for a few years now. Capaldi really damaged the brand by being the dr for way too long tbh

[Saph]

that being said, his final series with Bill was probably his best

[Marsh.]

Didn't Capaldi have the shortest tenure?

[Saph]

he had 3 I think

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Saph

he had 3 I think

No, but episode-wise, his was the shortest tenure.

[Saph]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

No, but episode-wise, his was the shortest tenure.

oh im not sure.. each of his eps felt about 7 hours long

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Saph

oh im not sure.. each of his eps felt about 7 hours long

He was a good Doctor though, despite his less than ideal companion and some of the writing.

There's some cracking stand alone eps.

[Saph]

2 with that Clara who was just awful

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by Saph

2 with that Clara who was just awful

I liked Clara but I was utterly sick of her by Capaldi. I loved Bill though, wish her and Twelve were still there...