[Tom]

I've found Xtra Factor to be better than the main show this year, its just took the complete p*ss, isn't so serious like the main show and it has Holly Willoughby

I've found myself looking forward to Xtra Factor more than the main show this year.

So which is best this year?

[Sam]

X Factor.

[Callum]

X Factor by a mile.

[Princess]

X Factor but The Xtra Factor is brill this year,especially Presinators!(or whatever its called)

[Emzy-!!]

X factor.

Can I ask if Xtra factor didn't have Holly willoughby would you still like it more???

[Corkie]

I like xtra factor better. But Holly is a main factor in me liking it.
But it has been brill and I agree it doesn't take itself serious.

louis' limericks are wizard

[Tom]

Originally posted by Emzy-!!
X factor.

Can I ask if Xtra factor didn't have Holly willoughby would you still like it more???

Probably, Holly is just a bonus though. Its a lot different this year than it has been in past years. It used to just be a follow on but this year its more focused on bad acts and is just completely random ...

[Spike]

Xtra Factor is much better. More fun and light hearted, X Factor should try being abit more like it

[Locke.]

X Factor, don't like Xtra Factor.

[SammyAyee]

Both are good
But i prefer The X Factor


But The Xtra Factor is funny though

[Dan_]

X-Factor, Holly's started to slightly get on my nerves on Xtra Factor.

[Billy]

X Factor, I prefer the seriousness to it

[netgearbbfan]

I love it when the x factor goes live i hope the set has a new look it had the same for two years

[LemonJam]

I find that X Factor has good singers but its as cheesey as a brie production factory.

The Xtra Factor would be good but they only show bad singers.

So I'm undecided.

[Annie]

I voted Xtra Factor as the one I enjoy more to watch as its just fun and not taken too seriously and when the live shows are on I really enjoy the interviews after the show etc.

But I do also love the seriousness of the X Factor show and how they build a lil bit of tension before each audition and before the live show and performances.