[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

1) Okami (Wii)
2) Dead Space 2 (360)
3) Fallout New Vegas (360)
4) Bioshock (360)
5) Super Mario Galaxy 2 (Wii)

[Locke.]

Fifa 11
Fifa 10
Fifa 09
Fifa 08
Fifa 07

[Tom4784]

You're kinda cheating with Okami but I'm just being pedantic.

I don't think I could pick a definitive top 5 but in this moment I think I'd say.

1) Left 4 Dead 2 - It's a game I always go back to and given that I generally hate FPS games it's an achievement.
2) Mass Effect 2 - Just immense all round.
3) Elder Scrolls IV - You can play it for weeks without touching the main story missions and not get bored.
4) Street Fighter 4 (and it's various iterations) - One of the best Fighting Games in years.
5) Bayonetta - Just ridiculously fun and insane.

[Novo]

Elder Scrolls IV The Mass Effect series and Fallout 3 are the main three

[Smithy]

omg, Okami

[Grimnir]

1. Gears of War
2. Bioshock
3. Gears of War 2
4. Resident Evil 5
5. GTA IV

still not played Red Dead Redemption but it looks a great game from video footage and want to play next and that might make top 5 when I do