[Josy]

Quite a few of them were pretty disappointing tonight IMO

Luke - Was really surprised at him tonight because I think he's been great most weeks, not sure if it was his song choice or not but I just thought he was a bit meh during his performance.

Rough Copy - I love these guys and think they will go far whether they win or not but I think they sounded pretty awful at the beginning of that song.

Hannah - I don't know I just think she's been getting worse every week and is only able to sing certain types of songs, I'm finding her voice to be irritating as the show goes on too and still think she's a complete misery guts.

Had a feeling Tamera was going to forget her lines too

Just my opinions....

[reece(:]

It was the worst show of the series tonight, everyone downgraded from last week.

[Vicky.]

I really really liked Lukes.

Rough Copy were painful. They couldnt hit the high notes at all and sounded terrible..usually like them too but this week and last..no.

Tamera, predictable tbh. Memory of a goldfish was proven at auditions

Hannah is really bad. Ever since she started on the happy pills rather than constantly crying her voice has got worse and worse. Shes gotta be B2 again

Nicholas was amazing. But he does the same thing every week really

First week I havent liked Sam B. I think song choice was the problem, never heard it before and do not like it.

Sam C..I starting to feel sorry for him so I'm not hating on him as much as I probably should be

[Josy]

Originally Posted by Vicky.

I really really liked Lukes.

Rough Copy were painful. They couldnt hit the high notes at all and sounded terrible..usually like them too but this week and last..no.

Tamera, predictable tbh. Memory of a goldfish was proven at auditions

Hannah is really bad. Ever since she started on the happy pills rather than constantly crying her voice has got worse and worse. Shes gotta be B2 again

Nicholas was amazing. But he does the same thing every week really

First week I havent liked Sam B. I think song choice was the problem, never heard it before and do not like it.

Sam C..I starting to feel sorry for him so I'm not hating on him as much as I probably should be

I'm feeling sorry for him too lately, he clearly can't sing but yet every week you can actually see the pain on his face from him trying so hard, that's why I deliberately left him out of my OP because I always say something bad about him

[Natalie.]

I really didn't enjoy tonight's episode, I don't know what can be done to make it better

[Mystic Mock]

I thought Luke was good this week, I liked the fact that he didn't carbon copy Elton John's version of the song.

[Vanessa]

Luke was amazing! Can't wait to download the song.

[joeysteele]

I agree but I think the problem is that for a lot of people they compare the performances to the originals,especially if they know those performances well.

Tamera forgot a line but recovered but really how can you forget a line or word from that song being a James Bond theme too.

I was disappointed with Sam Bailey too, somehow she didn't do a spectacular performance of Something, My Dad has a dvd of Shirley Bassey singing that and really, that is the way to do that song, no other way.

Luke I thought did good to be fair, not outstanding but better than I thought for such a well known song.

Nicholas has a great voice, no denying but this is all we seem to be getting from him. I would listen to a cd of him but would I pay to go and see him,I doubt it.

Hannah, oh dear, just didn't work for me, all we got was the chorus of the song really and barely one verse, not her best night.

Sam Callahan, I like this guy and hopes he'd do really good as Faith is not a vocally demanding song, it went a bit all over the place but I still hope he can be there next week, his vocal was better definately this week.

Rough Copy, I forget who it was but I think Simon had a group do this song some years back, they did it far better, I felt Rough Copy were one of the worst of the night.

They were too well known songs and really these acts had little scope to make any of them their own, stray too far from the original and it could be disaster, stay close to the original and that is what you will compared to.

They really need to do something with X Factor as to performances, the butchering as to running time of songs like these, spoils the songs, a slightly longer performing time to do real justice to the songs is badly needed in my view.

Less chat from Dermot and the Judges and more singing from the acts is what I'd like to see.

[Vanessa]

Originally Posted by joeysteele

I agree but I think the problem is that for a lot of people they compare the performances to the originals,especially if they know those performances well.

Tamera forgot a line but recovered but really how can you forget a line or word from that song being a James Bond theme too.

I was disappointed with Sam Bailey too, somehow she didn't do a spectacular performance of Something, My Dad has a dvd of Shirley Bassey singing that and really, that is the way to do that song, no other way.

Luke I thought did good to be fair, not outstanding but better than I thought fdor such a well known song.

Nicholas has a great voice, no denying but this is all we seem to be getting from him. I would listen to a cd of him but would I pay to go and see him,I doubt it.

Hannah, oh dear, just didn't work for me, all we got was the chorus of the song really and barely one verse, not her best night.

Sam Callahan, I like this guy and hopes he'd do really good as Faith is not a vocally demanding song, it went a bit all over the place but I still hope he can be there next week, his vocal was better definately this week.

Rough Copy, I foget who it was but I think Simon had a group do tis song some years back, they did it far better, I felt Rough Copy were one of the worst of the night.

They were too well known songs and really these acts had little scope to make any of them their own, stray too far from the original and it could be disaster, saty close to the original and that is what you will compared to.

They really need to do something with X Factor as to performances, the butchering as to truning time of somngs like these, spoils the songs, a slightly longer performing time to do real justice to the songs is badly needed in my view.

Less chat from Dermot and the Judges and more singing from the acts is what I'd like to see.

[Jamie585]

Probably one of the worse live shows ever tbh...

Hannah - Though she sang well, but she is just so forgetable and think sh's in danger again this week
Luke - An ok vocal but ok isn't good enough in week 6 pretty disappointing
Sam B - Good vocal as always buy wrong song and wasn't her best
Rough copy - Not sure about them this week, very vanilla as nicole said.. something was missing
Sam C - Words cant describe how bad he was, just awful.
Tamera - Very disappointing even without her mess up wasn't bad but wasn'tas good as she should be
Nicholas - Best out of a bad bunch.. good vocal but lacked originality.

[Vanessa]

I didn't like Sam Baily tonight. Wrong song choice maybe?

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Vanessa

I didn't like Sam Baily tonight. Wrong song choice maybe?

Definitely a wrong song choice, she even didn't come across on it as powerful as she has on other songs.
She obviously didn't watch Shirley Bassey performing it, had she done so she would have realised the mountain she had to climb to pull it off.

[GiRTh]

I've tried to watch the uploaded vids but couldnt sit thru any of them. Sam C was particularly painful.

[Shaun]

Staggered that people don't know "Something" by the Beatles... then again, no I'm not.

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Staggered that people don't know "Something" by the Beatles... then again, no I'm not.

Really? I give up.