[SairBabi92]

Both of these are X Factor winners and both have released new singles but who's single do you like better?

And who do you prefer as an artist?

Youtube video

OR

Youtube video

[Loukas]

THAT IS REALLY HARD

leona - GREAT VOICE
shayne- FIIITTTT

[KKBL]

thats the firs time ive heard bleeding love and i have to say its realy good!

[Ruth*Star]

Leona because she has a better voice.

[beanny]

Shayne. His Music Is FAR Better

[Wasted]

Leona was my favourite on the X Factor, but that's as a contestant.

But as an artist.... it's still Leona. Shayne's voice is great but Leona's is incredible and she eclipses him in terms of talent. Even her pre-X Factor material is better than Shayne's current releases. I don't like the songs he's released lately, If That's OK With You and No You Hang Up. I think he has a great voice but needs better songs. I would actually buy his album or something but I don't like the songs I've heard so far unfortunately. I love Bleeding Love, and Leona was superb at her Album Launch Party.

[CassetteFinger]

Leona who ever says shayne they fancy him its a well known fact thats why he won.

[xDramatick]

Shayne
I think he's got an amazing voice, though Leona has had better songs, she sounds like pretty much everyone else.

[CassetteFinger]

Originally posted by xDramatic
she sounds like pretty much everyone else.

what ?

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Rice_Square

what ?

Whitney
Christina
Mariah
Celine etc.

Sure, Shayne does sound like Justin at times, but I can distinctly tell him apart.
Leona's harder because her voice is a lot like the others, and I think someone more individual should have won.

[Tom4784]

I like Leona better, she's amazing.

[XxShortyxX]

Defo Leona! Better singer then Shayne, better song then Shayne's, better person then Shayne, more talent then Shyane, I could go on

Plus I can't stand Shayne bl**dy annoying Ward!

[CassetteFinger]

Originally posted by xDramatic

Whitney
Christina
Mariah
Celine etc.

Sure, Shayne does sound like Justin at times, but I can distinctly tell him apart.
Leona's harder because her voice is a lot like the others, and I think someone more individual should have won.

I see your point i dont think leona sounds like christina or celine or whitney and the only time she sounds like mariah is when she does those whistle notes she sounds like leona none of the rest on the list just cause she can sings big long notes dosent mean she sounds the same as the whitney or christina so you know.

[Wasted]

I find it easy to differentiate Leona's voice from the likes of Whitney, Christina etc. I could recognise her voice straight away.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Wasted
I find it easy to differentiate Leona's voice from the likes of Whitney, Christina etc. I could recognise her voice straight away.

I agree. Like on X Factor lost week when they played her song at the end I knew straight away it was her. Leona is a million times a better singer then Shayne. She could sing anything.

[XxShortyxX]

last*

[andybigbro]

Shayne
Ateast he has more than two songs out

[001steven]

Leona has the voice but i cant stand any x factor stars lol

[BBCH:fan]

i like leona