[Indierock&roll]

Right....
I dont mind hope ... i only like pheobe in it but they sound good together but last night they were NOT as good as the judges made out :|
Bits were good but it sounded really bad at most parts...

what does everyone else think?...

[Arneldo]

They bored me. They are not as good as people think they are. To me, they had some of the worst vocals of the night. They ruined that song and bored me to tears.

[Loukas]

i totaly disagree

there voices were MENT to be together

the uk need a band like hope

if the push it to there best THEY CAN STORM THE WORLD

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
i totaly disagree

there voices were MENT to be together

the uk need a band like hope

if the push it to there best THEY CAN STORM THE WORLD

I agree, them along with Niki were defo the best last night!

You want bad and awful,and messed up then that's Leon, he was terrible last night, and so should of been in the bottom two.

[SairBabi92]

I don't like them at all but i don't know why lol if that makes any sense?

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
i totaly disagree

there voices were MENT to be together

the uk need a band like hope

if the push it to there best THEY CAN STORM THE WORLD

They are just another manufactured girl band. They are very poor mans Pussycat Dolls. The didn't have enough talent to get into the judges houses alone and to me nothing has changed. They dont have very strong voices, they dont have a any spark.

[Loukas]

thats an opinion

that was week 1

lets see what week 2 brings

[Matt08]

I liked their voices but maybe Umberella wasn't the song for them. I do a agree that they are very slightly over-rated.

[Indierock&roll]

I like them , they are the best out of the groups but that wasnt good vocaly to be honest!

I actually thought leon was good it was just really really messy :|
andy seemed nervous but he did sound really good and when he gets a great song he will be amazingg love him! and hes welsh

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by DoubleTrouble
thats an opinion

that was week 1

lets see what week 2 brings

Of course it's an opinion, my opinion.

It's not just week one. The haven't been very good since they were formed.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Arneldo

They are just another manufactured girl band. They are very poor mans Pussycat Dolls. The didn't have enough talent to get into the judges houses alone and to me nothing has changed. They dont have very strong voices, they dont have a any spark.

They are a million times better than PCD. They all sing, not just one singing

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy

They are a million times better than PCD. They all sing, not just one singing

One singing in PCD is a trillion times better then the whole of Hope put together. They are not the best in the compatition, far from IMO. They have no spark, no star quality and they just dont look right. Lst night they ruined that song, and lookedlike prostatuites while doing it. Sadly they will win. Why? Because Simon wants them to win.

[XxShortyxX]

One singing in PCD is a trillion times better then the whole of Hope put together. They are not the best in the compatition, far from IMO. They have no spark, no star quality and they just dont look right. Lst night they ruined that song, and lookedlike prostatuites while doing it. Sadly they will win. Why? Because Simon wants them to win. [/quote]


I disagree. They could be the next Girls Aloud. Girls will like them, and at least they have a personality and can sing unlike some in the Comperation.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
One singing in PCD is a trillion times better then the whole of Hope put together. They are not the best in the compatition, far from IMO. They have no spark, no star quality and they just dont look right. Lst night they ruined that song, and lookedlike prostatuites while doing it. Sadly they will win. Why? Because Simon wants them to win.

I disagree. They could be the next Girls Aloud. Girls will like them, and at least they have a personality and can sing unlike some in the Comperation. [/quote]

I have yet to see personality in any of them bar Rochelle. They are far from being the next Girls Aloud, IMO. Girls Aloud actually have a lot of talent. I'm not denying they can sing, but they are not the best in the competition. There are far better singers and performers IMO.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Arneldo

I disagree. They could be the next Girls Aloud. Girls will like them, and at least they have a personality and can sing unlike some in the Comperation.

I have yet to see personality in any of them bar Rochelle. They are far from being the next Girls Aloud, IMO. Girls Aloud actually have a lot of talent. I'm not denying they can sing, but they are not the best in the competition. There are far better singers and performers IMO. [/quote]


Like? Boring Andy? Dull Leon? Put you to sleep Daniel? The Chavs Futureproof?

The girls this year are so much better then the guys.

Imo, Niki and Hope are the best singers, with SD, Bev and Emily next.

[Billy]

GA ahve talent? Did you watch Postars teh Rivals

[Wasted]

Originally posted by AndyToWin
Right....
I dont mind hope ... i only like pheobe in it but they sound good together but last night they were NOT as good as the judges made out :|
Bits were good but it sounded really bad at most parts...

what does everyone else think?...

I agree with you, I thought they did a better job of it at Simon's house. I didn't like the backing track, I didn't like what they were wearing, I didn't like how they were standing really far apart and divided up when they're supposed to be a group, and I didn't like the monotonous vocals. It was boring and disappointing, because I actually thought they'd turn out to be the best of the night. They can do much better.

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
GA ahve talent? Did you watch Postars teh Rivals

No but I have heard their songs and watched their videos.

[Billy]

They cant sing live for toffee

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX

I have yet to see personality in any of them bar Rochelle. They are far from being the next Girls Aloud, IMO. Girls Aloud actually have a lot of talent. I'm not denying they can sing, but they are not the best in the competition. There are far better singers and performers IMO.

Like? Boring Andy? Dull Leon? Put you to sleep Daniel? The Chavs Futureproof?

The girls this year are so much better then the guys.

Imo, Niki and Hope are the best singers, with SD, Bev and Emily next. [/quote]

I think Niki, Beverley, Rhydian, Emily, Daniel, Andy, Alisha, FP, SD & even Kim all have better vocals then Hope. Hope are okay as a group but separately they are woeful, as proved in Boot Camp. They dont work together and I think they took the place of another band that should in the Final 12.

I think Hope have not got great vocals, have no star quality, have no charisma and just dont work together

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy
They cant sing live for toffee

I have seen them live and I disagee. They are brilliant live.

[Billy]

LOL ok

[Wasted]

Originally posted by Billy
They cant sing live for toffee

I disagree. I'm not a fan but they do have good singers in the group. I don't recall what they were like during Popstars the Rivals, singing as individuals, all I remember was that Nadine was very good, but I think all 5 of them can sing and it's easy to distinguish between their individual voices as well.

And Hope are lacking something that Girls Aloud have. Girls Aloud have a better chemistry amongst each other, but I'm not feeling that with Hope.

[XxShortyxX]

The defo work together! You can see that when they sing, they defo have charisma. Dan, Leon, And are all boring, and they way they sing is boring. Maybe it's the song they sung, but it bored me, and they don't have a personality between them. leon was the worst singer last night, it was like watching a robot, yet he got through, only because he was a guy.

And FP, are just sooooooo rubbish and annoying, I hope they go next week!

I think Niki is with out any doubt the best singer.

[Billy]

Ill agree to that Wasted. Nadine can sing, and they have ahd some good songs, but looking at Hope and Girls Aloud (remembering GA was in teh same position as them), Hope are individually so muhc better vocalists