[elliebrew]

I hate to say it, cos siavash has been my favourite for a while, but im back noirin in that arguement, He lied and shudnt have done, freddie backing him u and lying was just as bad

I see Noirin is hated on here a lot, but come on guys...

I mean i know she promised not to say anything...but if u were her, i would want to know if people think i was a rabbit, sorry...

She did NOT plan to tell everyone that it was Siavash who said it, she remained calm and did not jump to the chance to sell out Siavash which is exactly what she should of done in the first place to show how much of a bloody liar and evil ****** he really is.]

Also Halfwits outburst was totally bulls**t and he does not even know what went on so he had no bloody right telling her what to do.

I'm sorry but i felt bad for Noirin there, she did not deserve to get played like that, then the only person that was there to possibly give evidence was Marcus and he left her in the lurch to face that mob!

People are gonna say...oh noirins a bitch blah blah....but you know she was *********g right there.

[Zerger0]

But he wasnt lying :\, one of the few times Siavash actually says anything about another housemate and Noirin just goes and does that. She knew it would start something.

[elliebrew]

He was lying, kris and karly never said that.

Believe me i hate admitting it but its true

[Stephanie]

karly and kris said about her jumping from group to group, they didn't call her a rabbit, that's just how siavash explained it.

[MissKittyFantastico]

Originally posted by elliebrew
He was lying, kris and karly never said that.

Believe me i hate admitting it but its true

They DID say it though! 2 days ago at the bus stop when talking to Lisa, who said the same thing! Siavash overheard them!

[cleaner67]

Didn`t he overhear them say it the other night

[bovvered?]

Nobody will trust her again.
She now has alienated herself from both groups.

[Stealthwolf]

Exactly!
Sure, I don't like how Noirin kind of turned on him, and I really wish she hadn't said anything to the group or just brushed off the comment since everybody talks about everybody and she needs to realize she is no exception.

But I've yet to hear exactly what SHE said that Siavash was threatening to expose her for saying about the "Cool" clique.

"I'll never tell them what you said about them"
"What did I say"

Indeed. What did she say? She never said anything. Not in that exchange at least.

And has anyone found out one way or another whether or not Kris and Karly actually said "she moves from group to group" with the "Bunny Rabbit" metaphor being a move of creative nicknaming on Siavishe's part (because I agree with Marcus...no way in the world they could ever come up with anything clever. Ever.)

[Smugington]

I find Rabbit to be the single most offensive insult ever conceived, i'm sure Gavin complained to ofcom regarding this obscenity.

[Blink_Me]

Originally posted by cleaner67
Didn`t he overhear them say it the other night

Yeah. He just didn't word it correctly.

[Shasown]

He heard them say it at the bus stop.

The bit I like was she had promised not to mention it before he would tell her how she seemed to others.

The editing was quite bad, it didn't resemble the full arguement, nor did it cover her pulling matcus out of bed to back her up, marcus' reaction, her comments to Freddie, and her diary room chat

[Twilight]

They did say that about her but like stefani said " they didn't call her a rabbit, that's just how siavash explained it"
So he and Freddie didn't lie.

[vgh50]

so have you changed your mind now ellie, or do you still back the evil bitch?

[Yatir48]

Changing the subject, but who was it, Kris or Marcus, who said that Sophie might go because she was so quiet? They both denied actually saying this.

[Iceman]

Why did he bactrack in the middle of an argument then???

[setanta]

have they seriously mentioned it before? i mean the hopping from group to group?

i'm not sure how relevant it is though cuz i think she really betrayed them all by making such a big deal about it. i don't think the highlight show emphasised how vindictive she is......she was swearing and shouting and being bitchy about it all night on live feed.

[sunshine_babe]

I dont how anyone can blame Noirin for wanting to know who said what & why she was dubbed "rabbit".

[Indierock&roll]

the only time he lied was when he said he didnt say those names,
he only said that because he didnt want it to get out which is why he told noirin not tell, and she swore she wouldnt but she did.

and karly and kris did say it so. they were lying saying they would "never say anything about her because they like her"

[Iceman]

Hmm still lied, was a good argument though brightened up the week.

[Blink_Me]

Originally posted by Iceman
Why did he bactrack in the middle of an argument then???

Imagine if you was getting shouted at by 5 people at the same time.

[Iceman]

Originally posted by Blink_Me

Imagine if you was getting shouted at by 5 people at the same time.

Eh, I wouldn't try and lie my way out of what I was saying...

[MissKittyFantastico]

Originally posted by Stealthwolf
Exactly!
Sure, I don't like how Noirin kind of turned on him, and I really wish she hadn't said anything to the group or just brushed off the comment since everybody talks about everybody and she needs to realize she is no exception.

But I've yet to hear exactly what SHE said that Siavash was threatening to expose her for saying about the "Cool" clique.

"I'll never tell them what you said about them"
"What did I say"

Indeed. What did she say? She never said anything.

And has anyone found out one way or another whether or not Kris and Karly actually said "she moves from group to group" with the "Bunny Rabbit" metaphor being a move of creative nicknaming on Siavishe's part (because I agree with Marcus...no way in the world they could ever come up with anything clever. Ever.)

We don't know what Noirin said about the vile group (if anything) because by the time LF came on last night the 'rabbit' discussion had already taken place and it would have been edited tonight. Noirin herself said that she hadn't said anything she wouldn't say to their faces, including the fact that she didnt trust Karly, but she KNEW that Siavash wouldn't come out and say any of it because he doesn't break confidences, unlike Noirin herself.

Lisa, Karly and Kris ALL called Noirin a 'group jumper' 2 days ago when sat at the bus stop...and Siavash was there and heard them say it...that was on LF.

So yes he did lie and say he never said the names Karly and Kris, obviously trying to cover for them, landing himself totally in the **** at the same time.

At the end of the day he regarded Noirin as his friend and was trying to help her out, and she royally screwed him over. He shouldn't have lied....he should have just come out and pointed the finger at karly and Kris but he didn't, and was trying to cover his ass at the same time.

[setanta]

she was told something in confidence btween friends. the way she reacted to it was horrendous- turning into a witch- hunt. how mature. and she was swearing all through it on live feed.

[Stealthwolf]

There was certainly a better way for handling it.

And I just kept saying over and over while watching "YOU PROMISED YOU WOULDN'T SAY ANYTHING"

It irritates me to no end when people can't keep their word.

[officialleafan]

I back....BOTH of them. I can understand that Siavash may have heard whatever he heard lol. But who was it that was saying that? Hmm? Wouldn't be Karly and Lisa would it?

I know a lot of people hate Noirin, as the OP said, but both her and Siavash ARE victims of bitching, which has lead to this huge argument.

I still like them both equally the same, although i think Siavash has dug his own grave. Noirin is very honest and if something happened to me like that, i'd do exactly the same as her.