[Janette]

Who do you think will be the class A student and the three singing for survival this week?

My choices are:-

Class A - Sinead

Probationers - Marli David Malachi

[Scotty]

Class A - Ainslie, he is by far the most creative and has the most original voice. He has an unique style and is the only student with true star quality.

Probationers - Katie, Nigel & Pippa

[Mairi]

Ooooooh, Janette, NO WAY will Malachi be on probation next week after his performance tonight. He was STONKING!! He's hopeless at dancing and he's tried SO hard this week to get those steps right, bless him.

Class A student: Malachi (or Sinead)

3 on probation: this is hard but I think I'll go for David, Pippa and Marli.

[susieq]

I think the A Grade student should be Sinead.

The three probationers: Nigel, Katie (again - sorry) and Pippa.

[Scotty]

I suppose I can't argue too much with the above, Sinead is very good too.

[finch]

Sinead she is the last of the top level.

I think it's already between Marli, Lemar, Ainslie and Sinead.
It will be interesting who gets it after Sinead.

probationers - Pippa, david, Nigel


I don't think Malachi can sing that well

[BigSister]

Grade A student Ainslie or Sinead cant choose

Probation- Katie (again sorry), David and
Pippa

[Amy]

A grade student = Sinead

Probation = Marli, Malachi and Katie

[LEE]

Like most of you I would choose either Ainslee or Sinead as Grade A student.

Probationers are more difficult to choose - I would definitely go for Katie and Pippa but I'm not sure about a third. I think I would probably go for Malachi as I don't think he has a very good voice and has never impressed me as much as the others.

I really like Marli and there's no way I think she should be a probationer and I also like Nigel and hope he's not on probation, although I probably think he will be.

[BusyBee]

Grade A student has got to be Sinead = she is fantastic with a wonderful voice

Probationers - Pippa, Marli (she seems to have gone downhill since being voted Grade A student) and either Malachi or Nigel.

Well done Katie for getting through.

[peachy]

Grade A student = Sinead

Probationers = Nigel (I'm not at all keen, I'm afraid, and he doesn't really fit in)

Katie = although she was a bit better on Friday

and I think it will possibly be Pippa or David, although they could also decide to give Marli a bit of a shock and put her on probation this week.

[Romantic Old Bird]

I too think it will be Sinead as grade A

I think Malachi will be on probation as he didn't really stand out in that trio, along with Katie (who surely HAS to go) and maybe Marli

[bbceleb1]

A= Sinead

P= Marli
P=Pippa
P=David

[Maggie]

A = Sinead

P =Marli

P = Katie

P = Malachi

[WILDCHILD]

I think Sinead will definetely be the A student. As for the probationers - who knows?? I will be interested to find out.

[Janette]

Congratulations susieq, you were absolutely correct

I still think Marli should be on probation and not Nigel, but at least he will get the chance to shine again on Friday night

[Amy]

Well done to Sinead She deserves to be Grade A student!
I'm shocked at the three on probation, like you Janette, i thought Marli would be one of them

[LEE]

I'm not particularly surprised at the probationers.

Katie should have gone by now - how she's managed to survive the last couple of weeks I'm still not sure. Pippa is just not remarkable at all and even though I like Nigel and didn't want him to be on probation, I'm not at all surprised that he is.

I never thought Marli deserved probation.

Sinead deserved grade a, and I agree with the students who are on probation. I just hope Nigel goes, he sounds like he is on karoke and his personality is.... annoying.

[Janette]

The problem with Nigel is that he's never going to be a pop singer, he's rock through and through.

As much as I like him and want him to do well, he shouldn't really be on Fame Academy because all the teachers seem to want is a pop star, and I can't really see Nigel going along with that!

[finch]

hello that's why it's fame academy not PopIdol or Popstars

[kaphc]

I think there is room for Nigel with his rock voice - I think the problems have been that his voice is a bit one-dimensional. However, when he sang the soul duet with Camilla a couple of weeks back, he proved that he could adapt to different types of song.

Ainslie is a typical "indie" type singer as well, but he's a bit more adaptable at different types of songs than Nigel.

[Maggie]

I like a good rock voice, as for Ainslie, I don't think he'd make a popstar either, I do hope Fame is not just about making a popstar, there are some really great singers in the music world, it dos'nt always have to be pop.

[em]

theyre not looking specifically for a pop singer. the teachers love Ainslie and Lemar and u could hardly push their voices in to a pop song! thats why they dont sing them.

[finch]

Even Marli and lemar don;t have straight pop voices