[Jodie.]

Say which series you feel done better in these areas

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB18

Eye:
Graphics:
House Design:
Emma’s excitement:
Arguments:
Fun:
Tasks:
Overall:

[Epic.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma's excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB18

so many options yet 'Cast' isn't one of them

[TomC]

I'm quite liking BB18 at the moment, but compared to the first two weeks of last year, BB18 isn't a patch on 17.

[Epic.]

BB17 is so overrated imo. The only time I really enjoyed it was the first two/three weeks

[Oaker]

Originally Posted by Epic.

BB17 is so overrated imo. The only time I really enjoyed it was the first two/three weeks

Week 3 and the last week sucked but the other ones were good

[Daniel-X]

I loved BB17, BB18 is okay at the moment but I doubt I'll look back on it like 'oh that was a really good series'

[Jodie.]

Originally Posted by Epic.

so many options yet 'Cast' isn't one of them

I thought that was abit too general, so I split it into arguments and fun x

[Jodie.]

If BB17 had Chanelle and Raph

[supertv247]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB17
Twists: BB17
Cast: BB17
Overall: BB17

But... BB18 isn't that bad

[*mazedsalv**]

Considering it's only been 2 weeks I can't comment on twists, tasks and "overall" as there haven't really been any twists really and only 1 shopping task.

But others...

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Cast: BB17

First 2 weeks of BB17- 8.5/10
First 2 weeks of BB18- 3/10

[Time]

BB17 was pretty good so it'll take something to top it. BB18 was quite **** to start with, but I'm starting to get into it now.

[armand.kay]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jason.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17 (The graphics for that series were great)
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: Hard to tell, she hasn't been excited since Secrets & Lies
Arguments: BB17 (bc Natalie and they weren't as draining as this year's)
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jodie.]

Anyone changed opinions?

I’d probably rate BB18’s arguments better than BB17 now

[Nicky91]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB18
House Design: BB18
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB17
Overall: BB17

[Cal.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Cal.]

BB18's tasks have had effort put into them. Sukhvinder being the Mayor BB17's was very much 'Who Said What?' and 'Eat something gross'.

Saying that most tasks have blended in together over the years .The last series that felt like there was a defined shopping task every week was BB15. I remember the farm one, the battery one, the murder mystery one, the Armageddon one etc.

[Jay28jay2]

Eye: 17
Graphics: 17
House Design: 18
Emma’s excitement: 17
Arguments: 18
Fun: 17
Tasks: None, they have all been awful in both seasons
Overall: Can't judge atm, wait till this season is over

[sungrass]

bb17 was great for me- great house mates and good ideas - sane people and nuts makes an interesting combination.

[sungrass]

Originally Posted by Jay28jay2

Eye: 17
Graphics: 17
House Design: 18
Emma’s excitement: 17
Arguments: 18
Fun: 17
Tasks: None, they have all been awful in both seasons
Overall: Can't judge atm, wait till this season is over

you forget Andys newscaster task which was hilarious - and the time Jayne fake fainted because a foam brick got chucked at her head - and Hughies drunken dancing

[Lostie!]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: No idea
Arguments: BB18
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

Both have been returns to form after the terrible couple of years with BB15 and BB16 though.

[Jake.]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB18
Arguments: BB17/18 (would probably rate them the same)
Fun: BB18
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

[Jodie.]

Anyone changed opinions yet? I’m sticking with what I said in the OP

But the gap is closing between what I prefer: BB17 or BB18. This last week has let it down a bit

[Oaker]

Eye: BB17
Graphics: BB17
House Design: BB17
Emma’s excitement: BB17
Arguments: BB17
Fun: BB17
Tasks: BB18
Overall: BB17

.

[Macie Lightfoot]

k so I only Wiki watched BB17 but I've found this year's tasks to be pretty ****ty. The ~Den of Dilemma~ hardly felt like a shopping task and it was just cobbled together to be done in a day and a half, and then the ~Survival Room~ was hilariously unimaginative as it was just a checklist of things for them to do to pass.