[sol]

I can understand why she was in the bottom 2 last week, I found her performance quite enjoyable
I wasnt surprised that 4tune were in the bottom 2.

I f i was voting it would have been 4tune and Chico in the bottom 2

Does anyone else have an opinion on why Chenai was put in the bottom 2 last week?

[Princess]

Well I really like Chenai,so I would end up be biased

[Ruth]

I didn't think she was that good, but waaaaaaaaaaay better than Philip, who I don't think sang a single note in tune.

[sol]

i know! tell me about it!

[Arneldo]

i thought she was good - better tan her first live performace..

shud hav been coco an phillip

[makosifan]

shes not my fav but i like Chenai think shes a lovely girl and she is a good singer.
Hope she does well in the show

[BigSister]

I thought it was ok didnt blow me away though but didnt deserve to be in bottom 2

[sol]

Originally posted by BigSister
I thought it was ok didnt blow me away though but didnt deserve to be in bottom 2

yer, thats exactly what i thought

[Dan_]

It was down there as one of the worst imo.

[Lance]

Well moi beeing a Chenai fan I am just a tad bias.

Bit I really don't think it was that bad...well not bad enought to be bottom two. I'lladmit it wasn't the best performance in the world, but it was good. A LOT better than Chico and Phillip.

Maria is ace though, she rocked last week.

[BigSister]

Yeah I agree lance it was better than Chico and Philip

[jrc]

I think it was shocking and she was pretty lucky to stay last week, considering who she was up against. However, I will concede that she's better than Chico.

[Pipergun]

Chenai's performance was ok... not the best in the world, but then she's never really blown me away .

I agree with you that she didn't deserve to be in the bottom two, compared with either Chico or Phillip who were chronic .

However, I think it came down to two things:

1. She performed quite early on in the show, and unless it's a stonking performance, it's easier to forget than those who perform later in the show.

2. The song IMO was quite karaoke, and not a song that a modern credible artist would normally sing: The upbeat tempo and disco style spelled trouble from the word go IMO.

I also saw this problem in Andy, who had a pretty bad song choice, and seemingly suffered as a result!

[sol]

Originally posted by Pipergun
Chenai's performance was ok... not the best in the world, but then she's never really blown me away .

I agree with you that she didn't deserve to be in the bottom two, compared with either Chico or Phillip who were chronic .

However, I think it came down to two things:

1. She performed quite early on in the show, and unless it's a stonking performance, it's easier to forget than those who perform later in the show.

2. The song IMO was quite karaoke, and not a song that a modern credible artist would normally sing: The upbeat tempo and disco style spelled trouble from the word go IMO.

I also saw this problem in Andy, who had a pretty bad song choice, and seemingly suffered as a result!

Yes, i totally agree

[Siouxsie]

not keen on her either