[DrunkerThanMoses]

Thoughts, should we have a say our say on who our final 12 are?

[Jack_]

Good question.

Didn't they do something like this on Pop Idol? They had 24 acts and before the Live Shows they presented some special live shows where we got to vote two acts into the Top 12, or something similar to that.

But to answer your question, I don't think so, usually the judges pick the best 12 anyway, and I like the XF format how it is.

[Kate!]

quite a good idea, but they will never do it, i also think it should just go to public vote each week, and no saving **** acts by louis allowed.pmsl.

[Beastie]

yeah they do this in american idol! yeah I agree we should have more choice who goes into the top 12.. but that means more money wasted on phone calls lol