[Arneldo]

.... I understand that title is very Cher but read on - It does lead somewhere
[I just realised that that rhymes! ]

If you could turn back time, who wouldn't you have evicted from each series? Who do you think should have stayed a few more week or deserved to make it to the final or even deserved to win?

I think Caggie & Nichola both should have stayed a bit longer in BB1. I don't think either did anything that bad to be evicted

Narinder in BB2 - A big character and a bitch who had more to show and more to offer.

Of course - Alison from BB3! I still can't see why she was evicted!? What did she do wrong? The public evicted her over boring Sandy and annoying Alex!

Anoushka, Justine, Sissy, Fed, Jon, Lisa, Tania & Nush were evicted before they should have been.

Victor. Over the years since BB5 I have learnt to like him. Jason should have gone instead of him. He deserved a place in the final.

Mary & Science. Mary had a lot more to offer and could have been a real star. Science was just entertainment in human form.

Lisa & Jayne stick out from BB7. It's hard to believe the public evicted Lisa over bore-fest Imogen & Mikey. Jayne could have brought a lot more to the show and I think she was very under-rated. I would say Grace, but for Grace to stay Nikki would have gone.

Seany, Billi, Charley, Shanessa & Gerry. Seany for pranks, Billi for game play, Charley for fights, Shanessa for out spoken and bitchyness & I think Gerry deserved a place in the final.

[geoking66]

Here's how I would have evicted them, in order from first eviction to winner (I don't care about additional housemate ordering at this point):

Big Brother 2000: Sada, Andy, Tom, Craig, Claire, Darren, Caroline, Nicola, Nick, Melanie, Anna

Big Brother 2001: Stuart, Amma, Penny, Elizabeth, Bubble, Dean, Josh, Narinder, Paul, Helen, Brian

Big Brother 2002: Sunita, Sandy, PJ, Lynne, Lee, Tim, Spencer, Sophie, Kate, Jonny, Adele, Alison, Jade (pre-CBB5), Alex

Big Brother 2003: As long as Anouska, Ray, or Lisa (don't ask me why, but I liked her) won, I don't care about the order, with Jon being one of the last to leave, but not the winner

Big Brother 2004: Ahmed, Vanessa, Stuart, Becki, Shell, Jason, Kitten, Dan, Emma, Marco, Victor (for entertainment only, hated him), Michelle, Nadia

Big Brother 2005: Orlaith, Sam, Eugene, Vanessa, Anthony, Mary, Roberto, Derek, Craig, Lesley, Kinga, Science, Maxwell, Saskia, Kemal, Makosi

Big Brother 2006: Bonnie, George, Pete, Shahbaz, Dawn, Sam, Michael, Jonathan, Spiral, Susie, Mikey, Sezer, Jayne, Imogen, Lisa, Glyn, Jennie, Lea, Grace, Nikki, Richard, Aisleyne

Big Brother 2007: Liam, Ziggy, Laura, Kara-Louise, Tracey, Jonty, Sam, Amanda, Brian, David, Jonathan, Shabnam, Nicky, Billi, Amy, Shanessa, Seány, Carole, Emily, Gerry, Lesley, Chanelle, Charley

These are based on three criteria: personal preference, how much they did in the house, how good of a hosuemate were they (whether I liked them or not).

For Big Brother 2007, this is probably the most changed Big Brother of them all. I'm in the minority, but I really liked the dynamic of the all-girl house and the first half of the series. It had some great characters, it was interesting to see a single-sex house, and I think that overall it was more fun to watch. Now we're stuck with extremely boring people that don't do anything. I really wish that Big Brother 2005 were on, I found that to be the most interesting, but I have a slight preference for Big Brother 2004.