[Tom]

what do you think of her?

I'm just interested because most people on here like Diana and when you say something bad you get jumped on for it. So firstly, how many people actually don't rate her and secondly which of the poll options most applies?

[pinkmichk]

shes ok i fail to see the hype and prefere a few others to her is what i am voting

i just dont see the appeal behind a anoying hand with a average voice *awaits being jumped on *

[GiRTh]

I think she's a good but not great singer. She has talent but no where near as much as everybody claims. I think her biggest asset is her quirky delivery which, I think, is already wearing a bit thin. I dont think she should have made the final 12. I think Hannah should have been picked because Hannah's performances during boot camp were much more impressive.

I think she will win the X-factor, embark on a solo career only to find that her limitation as a vocalist continually hamper her career. Then she'll be dropped by her record company.

[Billy]

Originally posted by GiRTh
I think she's a good but not great singer. She has talent but no where near as much as everybody claims. I think her biggest asset is her quirky delivery which, I think, is already wearing a bit thin. I dont think she should have made the final 12. I think Hannah should have been picked because Hannah's performances during boot camp were much more impressive.

I think she will win the X-factor, embark on a solo career only to find that her limitation as a vocalist continually hamper her career. Then she'll be dropped by her record company.

I respect peoples opinions who don't like Diana etc, but why would her limitations hamper her career?

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21

I respect peoples opinions who don't like Diana etc, but why would her limitations hamper her career?

You can only go so far and to last you need to reinvent yourself, and how can Diana do that?

[hannah.]

I just don't get her. She has a good voice but ruins it by being so nasal

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Billy21

I respect peoples opinions who don't like Diana etc, but why would her limitations hamper her career?

I beleive that to make it as a vocalist she needs to show more range. I think she'll be succesful for a few years and then people will grow tired of her. As some already have.

[LemonJam]

She's okay, my 3rd favourite but to be honest, the floods of Diana fans really put me off liking her. =\ That sounds really stupid and ignorant but... yeh.

[Red Moon]

Use to like her at first but I went off her voice.... it's sort of mosue like quality that sort goes in and out of key on every note.

It started to get to me and I was glad to have a break from it last week and I'm not look forward to her coming back.

No, I don't think she can win it, even with all the internet support she has... a most of the people who vote on the X-Factor can just about use a phone let alone a computer.

[Billy]

Originally posted by GiRTh

I beleive that to make it as a vocalist she needs to show more range. I think she'll be succesful for a few years and then people will grow tired of her. As some already have.

The other artists in Dianas genre don't have big voices, but it doesn't stop them from being successfull.

(im not trying to hijack the thread btw im just curious)

[Tom]

Originally posted by LemonJam
She's okay, my 3rd favourite but to be honest, the floods of Diana fans really put me off liking her. =\ That sounds really stupid and ignorant but... yeh.

I'm the same. I liked her at bootcamp and I want to keep liking her but I can't because of the annoying Diana fans and because the novelty of her has long gone.

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21

The other artists in Dianas genre don't have big voices, but it doesn't stop them from being successfull.

(Im not trying to hijack the thread btw Im just curious)

Short term success though, I doubt very much that most of the ones you're on about (out of interest, who?) will be around in 5 years time which is what X Factor aims to do.

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Billy21

The other artists in Dianas genre don't have big voices, but it doesn't stop them from being successfull.

(Im not trying to hijack the thread btw Im just curious)

When you say other people in her genre are you referring to the likes of Katie Melua and Norah Jones? They write their own songs so they control the quality of their material. If Diana doesnt write her own songs I think she's going to have trouble finding song writers who can write good songs for her.

[XxShortyxX]

I thin Diana will have a great career a head of her, and I wish her the best, if she doesn't win I can defo see her getting a contract. Me mum says that Diana reminds her of Kate Bush, and she did really well.

[mizzy25]

i dont like diana never have and wish she wud go. like someone has already said on here hannah was better than her but cheryl picked diana coz she was prettier imho. my niece said she thougt diana sounded like duffy! i think thats an insult to duffy. diana just has a very annoying nasal voice and her hand movemenst get right on my nerves

[XxShortyxX]

Oh yes, Diana is a very, very pretty girl, she defo has the X Factor look. She sounds like Duffy? I wouldn't say so, IMO she sounds a bit like Kate Bush, me mum says the same.