[Dance2Night]

She wont sing live because she will dance
also Womanizer isn't the sort of you can sing to
its a recorded dance track

[Red Moon]

Britney hasn't really sung live in years, so it won't come as any kind of shock to her fans or the general public.

I believe, it just a bad reflection of our fake society that the producers of the X-Factor have allowed this Woman to appear on a live singing show.

[Dance2Night]

Originally posted by Red Moon
Britney hasn't really sung live in years, so it won't come as any kind of shock to her fans or the general public.

I believe, it just a bad reflection of our fake society that the producers of the X-Factor have allowed this Woman to appear on a live singing show.

she has sold over 83 million records
say what you like she is the future Madonna

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Dance2Night
[she has sold over 83 million records

83 million tone deaf idiots who jumped on a band wagon...... that's amazing.

And you know, all 83 million of them would think she has never done anything wrong in her life and to say something against her is spiteful and a attack on themselves.

No come on, this woman is an average singer with problems.

[Matt08]

Originally posted by Dance2Night

she has sold over 83 million records
say what you like she is the future Madonna

The only reason she has sold 83 million records is because her songs are catchy. She has hardly any vocal talent. She's like an operating system, it must take the technicians weeks to perfect her voice and make it sound like Microsoft SAM.

[Dance2Night]

I don't care what anyone says
The only reason she doesn't sing live is because she dances
and she is an incredibly talented musician

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Dance2Night
I don't care what anyone says
The only reason she doesn't sing live is because she dances
and she is an incredibly talented musician

She's not a musician because she doesn't sing or play an instrument.

[Jack]

Originally posted by Gazbo

She's not a musician because she doesn't sing or play an instrument.

She does sing. She wouldn't be where she is today if she didn't.

[Callum]

Who cares?! I'm just greatful that she'll be in there, Same Difference never got all this stick for miming and Britney hasn't even mimed it yet :/

[M X]

Britney hardly ever sings live.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Jack

She does sing. She wouldn't be where she is today if she didn't.

No she talks then employs a PC to do the rest.

[Wildcat!]

Originally posted by Dance2Night
I don't care what anyone says
The only reason she doesn't sing live is because she dances
and she is an incredibly talented musician

Fair enough dude! I like your convictons!
Cant deny she got loads of fans, but a lot of people dont like her! I like some of her songs, but I never enjoy her perform.

[Callum]

Originally posted by Gazbo

No she talks then employs a PC to do the rest.

Give it a rest will you! You know fully well she can sing. How did she get where she is today if she can't sing?

[Wildcat!]

To be fair, britney build up her fanbase by singing, and being pretty good, with a sultry voice. But after she became famous, I dont think she did anything other than let producers turn her into whatever! But when Britney first came out, you cant deny she as a huge talent!

[Jack]

Originally posted by Gazbo

No she talks then employs a PC to do the rest.

Oh come on. All artists are at that nowadays (Rihanna?). You're only focusing on the Blackout era. I suggest you remind yourself of her earlier work.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Callum

Give it a rest will you! You know fully well she can sing. How did she get where she is today if she can't sing?

Good management, good PR, a relationship with Justin Timberlake, rivalry with Christina, a computer and of course - notoriety.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Callum
Give it a rest will you! You know fully well she can sing. How did she get where she is today if she can't sing?

Miming on the Mickey Mouse Club?

She is as much a manufactured celebrity as any one that has been on Big Brother in recent years.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Jack

Oh come on. All artists are at that nowadays (Rihanna?). You're only focusing on the Blackout era. I suggest you remind yourself of her earlier work.

Circus is hardly unplugged now is it? And no one does it to the extent that she does and if they come close (Rihanna) they at least make up for it by showing they can sing well by perforimg live once in awhile.

[Callum]

Originally posted by Gazbo

Good management, good PR, a relationship with Justin Timberlake, rivalry with Christina, a computer and of course - notoriety.

Rivalry with Christina? Come off it, they don't dislike each other. People just assume they do. Like Jack said it's 2008 who doesn't use a computer to edit their songs? Christina even does it.

[MrGaryy]

Originally posted by Callum

Rivalry with Christina? Come off it, they don't dislike each other. People just assume they do. Like Jack said it's 2008 who doesn't use a computer to edit their songs? Christina even does it.

I never said they disliked each other I merely pointed out that the media pinning them against each other benefited both of them greatly during the beginnings of the their careers.

Read my above post.

Yes Christina does it but you can still clearly hear her vocals.

[xDramatick]

Britney's not a musician because Musician implies they can play some sort of instrument. Yes, Britney's not the only one artist that uses a computer to edit her vocals, but Rihanna can't sing particularly well either, bad example. I'm not saying she can't sing at all, she obviously has some sort of vocal ability, just not that much. Most artists nowadays use computers for effect in their songs. Girls Aloud's "Sexy! No No No" used it for effect. Not because they can't sing, they've proved it in other songs. Same with Christina. The third chorus of KGB has clearly been edited, but everyone knows she's extremely capable of singing through a song.

Britney will more than likely mime, which is a shame because that'll lose her credibility [I certainly will lose respect for her, particularly after gaining it]. Miming, IMO, is the worst thing an artist can do. It's like saying 'I can't sing/I can sing but I can't be bothered to show it to you now.' I don't care if she sings over recorded vocals, just something to prove she can sing live. I know she'll dance but so do other artists, and they sing live/over recorded vocals. Yes, Same Difference did it, and I'm disappointed in them for doing it, however, they've nothing to prove. They sang live all last year throughout the contest, and Britney hasn't sung live for at least 4 years, and seeing as there is criticism about her voice, if she was to sing live, regardless of whether it's amazing, or decent, it'd prove a point to all those who say she can't.

[KKBL]

Britney plays the paino..doesnt that make her a musician?
people realy need to get over the miming thing.Britney sings pop-dance-electronic music which is supposed to make people dance.its impossible for her to sing most of her songs properly and dance at the same time.she is perfectly capable of singing all of her songs 100% live but her managment choose not to.

[SammyAyee]

Originally posted by Callum
Who cares?! I'm just greatful that she'll be in there, Same Difference never got all this stick for miming and Britney hasn't even mimed it yet :/

[M X]

Originally posted by Gazbo

Circus is hardly unplugged now is it? And no one does it to the extent that she does and if they come close (Rihanna) they at least make up for it by showing they can sing well by perforimg live once in awhile.

Omg, I'm actually laughing. Rihanna, singing good?..live? Noo!

Youtube video

Youtube video

Youtube video

Youtube video

Youtube video

Sure!, Rihanna is a great artist but nine times out of ten, live she is painful.

[ParentalAdvisory]

Originally posted by Dance2Night
she has sold over 83 million records
say what you like she is the future Madonna

I almost spat coffee all over my keyboard because of that post. Thanks for giving me such a good laugh.

Madonna has sheer raw talent.
Britney can "sing a bit".

As for the posts about other artists using computers (like Rihanna): the only thing that says is that there are a lot of "singers" out there who can't actually sing.

Listen to Christina Aguilera or Kelly Clarkson singing live. That's how a real singer sounds. Britney Spears is a gimmick. She has fans, but that doesn't mean she has talent.