[GreenQueen]

Not missing Simon C at all this year. I think the new judges are great. I heard that what they saved in Simon C's fee funded Red or Black......

Anyone missing the big arrogant one?

[Jordan.]

Gary is a prick and not even in a funny way, time to bring Simon back.

[Marc]

Gary has taken the obnixious tool role. But no I don't think it's any worse Simon-less

However Simon > any of the new judges

[Callum]

I prefer Simon to Gary but Gary is alright, better than Louis at least.

[Tom]

I can't stand Gary, he's a pretentious dickhead

if he's not being rude to someone he's just fading into the background. Gary may officially be Simons replacement but to me Kelly is the leading judge. shes the one that gives the good criticism, shes the one that puts the contestants firmly back into their place, she does the announcements and all that

Tulisa is OK but shes just kind of there

I miss Simon and Cheryl a bit. I forgot Dannii even used to be a judge until she was in one the clips last week

[Doogle]

sharon > kelly > simon > danni > louis > tulisa > cheryl > gary

[Callum]

I don't think there'll ever be a judge as good as Sharon again

[LaLaLand]

Originally Posted by Callum

I don't think there'll ever be a judge as good as Sharon again

This.

I don't miss Simon at all.

[reece(:]

gary is terrible, "if i get the groups or the overs im leaving"

[joeysteele]

I don't really miss Simon, I quite like this line up of judges and I also like Gary too but just wish he was wound up to talk a bit faster.

[_Seth]

I hate Gary, he's really annoying and smug. >_>

[Jords]

Cant stand Gary, would rather Simon back.

[Joelle.]

I was pretty shocked when he made the comment about leaving if he got the groups or overs.
Simon is sorely missed but as much as I loved Dannii, Tulisa and Kelly have made the show even better.