[Smithy]

Who, in your opinion has been the worst judge/mentor (you can have two if you think they were good at one but not the other) over the past 10 seasons?

[Kate!]

Mel B

[reece(:]

Geri Halliwell, Natalie Imbroglia.

[Smithy]

I think Louis is an awful judge, he literally never adds anything to panel, he just comes out with the same 5 cliché sayings every show, mentor wise probably sharon, even though she won this year thats purely been down to Sams talent and nothing else

[Me. I Am Salman]

Louis

[james130]

Kelendria as a mentor.
Tulisa as a judge.

[King Gizzard]

Louis

and as in who I think is the worst as in not liking them, Tulisa

[Z]

Louis for both. The man has nothing of value to say. He's a creepy wanker and I wish he'd disappear.

[Mystic Mock]

Worst Judge - Cheryl Cole (all she ever did was say you killed it or you smashed it, and attacked Aiden when the year before she Mentored Lloyd Daniels and Rikki Loney go figure)

Worst Mentor - Dannii Minogue (she just favours one act and treats the rest like crap, see TXFAUS this year)

[Me. I Am Salman]

Originally Posted by The Godinator

Worst Judge - Cheryl Cole (all she ever did was say you killed it or you smashed it, and attacked Aiden when the year before she Mentored Lloyd Daniels and Rikki Loney go figure)

Worst Mentor - Dannii Minogue (she just favours one act and treats the rest like crap, see TXFAUS this year)

Dannii was a great mentor

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Salman!

Dannii was a great mentor

The times she won anyone could've had them win, even a 2 year old could, especially with Matt Cardle.

[Vanessa]

Louis had two acts in the final, so no. I's Gary Barlow. He has never won the show!

[Marsh.]

Worst judge is Louis. Never has anything new to say, really doesn't even attempt to give constructive criticism. Should have gone years ago.

Worst mentor, probably all of them. Let's face it none of them are mentors. They sit and have discussions for the sake of the VTs, choose a song with them, fly off somewhere, then come back on Friday and watch them rehearse for a couple of hours, stay for the weekend shows and then the cycle goes on.

[Black Dagger]

Worst Judge - Tulisa, ****ing try-hard bint, and she was a miserable twat on her 2nd series. Louis is one of the best let's not.

Mentor - Kelly, over here. She clearly couldn't be ****ed, hence her ringing in sick one week, but I love her in the USA. She fits there, just like Nicole did here.

[Shaun]

Mentor: Kelly or Cheryl, neither of them seemed to give a toss about any of their acts other than Cher.
Judge: either of the Spice Girls. Vacuous, unpleasant people paid to act in a certain way by Cowell. Both completely talentless too.

[Marcus.]

Tulisa juge - added noughting

[Natalie.]

Tuliassa

[mizzy25]

Kelly both

[Jordan.]

Louis is a horrible little bitch & he clearly doesn't care as much about his contestants as he tries to pretend.

[Samm]

Tulisa

[Apple202]

Tulisa was a great mentor

Worst mentor Louis
Worst judges Louis/gary

[reece(:]

Tulisa was a good mentor to make LM marketable role models but the irony is she made herself look like an awful person so it sorta cancels it out.

[Apple202]

Her (grossly undeserved) unpopularity has got nothing to do with her mentoring abilities though

[GypsyGoth]

Louis is kinda the joke judge and mentor, so it'd be him.

In a way it's a shame that he's been on it so long, now it wouldn't seem the same if he left.

[bwoty]

Gary Barlow?

Longest serving judge to never win