[Headie]

Youtube video

[MB.]

It's no

Youtube video

[Mitchell]

You're seeming to forget that James Arthur won the show as well, every performance of his was a bad note

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Queen Mitchell

You're seeming to forget that James Arthur won the show as well, every performance of his was a bad note

James Arthur could sing, there's a difference between having a bad personality and disliking his Music to then call him a bad vocalist.

And tbh Hayden at least Ben did at least sing live tonight, what did Fleur do again? Oh yes mimed.

[T*]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

James Arthur could sing, there's a difference between having a bad personality and disliking his Music to then call him a bad vocalist.

And tbh Hayden at least Ben did at least sing live tonight, what did Fleur do again? Oh yes mimed.

James Ogre could not sing for ****

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Mistletom*

James Ogre could not sing for ****

He could, especially compared to any of this years lot and tbf last years lot too.

[Mitchell]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

James Arthur could sing, there's a difference between having a bad personality and disliking his Music to then call him a bad vocalist.

And tbh Hayden at least Ben did at least sing live tonight, what did Fleur do again? Oh yes mimed.

I disagree, I thought his voice was incredibly grunty, I personally don't think straining for a constipated poo is singing, but each to their own.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

James Arthur could sing, there's a difference between having a bad personality and disliking his Music to then call him a bad vocalist.

But that's exactly what you do with Fleur?

You don't like her style or music so you always criticise everything.

I'm no fan, but she clearly was singing live alongside Little Mix. There was a backing track, as always with pop stars but she was clearly singing.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

But that's exactly what you do with Fleur?

You don't like her style or music so you always criticise everything.

I'm no fan, but she clearly was singing live alongside Little Mix. There was a backing track, as always with pop stars but she was clearly singing.

I actually don't mind Fleur's single, I actually have liked a lot of other Hip Hop fusioned Pop songs in the past, I just think that Fleur cheats a lot live which I will comment on even after the show is over.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

I actually don't mind Fleur's single, I actually have liked a lot of other Hip Hop fusioned Pop songs in the past, I just think that Fleur cheats a lot live which I will comment on even after the show is over.

If a backing track is "cheating" then every pop star since the dawn of music is in trouble.

(or rather since the dawn of the playback)

[Jordan.]

I didn't notice this and I wish it stayed that way

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Nareindeer

Youtube video

I cringed every time he opened his gob
he murdered poor Leona's song but as usual Leona was amazing
but what a terrible duet why the hell did XF team Leona with Ben of all people their voices don't match

[Pete.]

Fleur didn't mime though - you could clearly hear her singing over the backing vocals

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Makosleigh

Fleur didn't mime though - you could clearly hear her singing over the backing vocals

No she mimed and let Little Mix sing the song for her.

There's one part of the song where her voice comes in and Fleur doesn't even have the mic to her mouth, don't you think that's even slightly odd?

[Pete.]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

No she mimed and let Little Mix sing the song for her.

There's one part of the song where her voice comes in and Fleur doesn't even have the mic to her mouth, don't you think that's even slightly odd?

This bit is clearly live

https://youtu.be/f9UvcGTwblA?t=219

[Headie]

Originally Posted by Makosleigh

Fleur didn't mime though - you could clearly hear her singing over the backing vocals

Don't feed the troll Pete

And I'd rather Ben mime next time so we don't have to suffer through that again lmao

[Ross.]

Erm Fleur wasn't miming

[Headie]

Originally Posted by Frossty

Erm Fleur wasn't miming

Those flawless live vocals >>>>> Benjamin whatshisname

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Nareindeer

Those flawless mime vocals >>>>> Benjamin whatshisname

That's more like it.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Nareindeer

Don't feed the troll Pete

And I'd rather Ben mime next time so we don't have to suffer through that again lmao

Oh Ben was bad but at least he still tried even though it was painful.

And what do you have against trolls.

[GoldHeart]

Originally Posted by Father Mockmas

Oh Ben was bad but at least he still tried even though it was painful.

And what do you have against trolls.

Ben destroyed that duet with Leona Lewis but because you like him you stick up for him
It was painful to listen to so poor Leona
Like I said what a terrible mismatch

[Northern Monkey]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

Ben destroyed that duet with Leona Lewis but because you like him you stick up for him
It was painful to listen to so poor Leona
Like I said what a terrible mismatch

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by GoldHeart

Ben destroyed that duet with Leona Lewis but because you like him you stick up for him
It was painful to listen to so poor Leona
Like I said what a terrible mismatch

I don't like Ben, I just dislike the way Simon and some Fleur fans are ripping him apart despite actually singing live unlike their favourite where Simon gives her everything including miming and her fans say nothing, even 1D sang live tonight and they're awful vocalists even on a good day so why couldn't Fleur sing live?

If anything after this weekend it validated me on my support for Lauren, Jack, OTY, and Andrea in their year as they never sounded like Ben did, and didn't mime like Fleur did.

This is why I never get winners on this show, they actually sing well live.

[Jay28jay2]

Youtube video

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Jay28jay2

Youtube video

I actually remember liking that performance up until the note.