[thisisme2008]

Who will replace Sharon?

[xDramatick]

Voted for Paula but I'd love Kylie+Kelly O+Lily.

[MrGaryy]

I actually think there's a good chance that Paula would do it. That would be a well rounded panel. It would cover the Australian, American, British and Irish market!

[Spike]

Paula would be great but I would also like to see Pete Waterman do it.

[Princess]

I think Sharon will come back.

[Noel]

I'd really love to see Paula Abdul join the X Factor. She's so bubbly and energetic and would certainly make sure that Sharon's humour isn't missed.

[bigbruvvaluvva]

amanda holden - she is already a popular judge on britains got talent and it would be a natural transition from BGT to TXF.

out of this list she is most likely to be simons choice IMO.

[Ross]

It was in the News Of The World today that Simon wants to replace her with Mel B I'd prefer Geri or Emma, but ok.

[Arneldo]

I have a gut feeling Sharon will be back.

But, if not then I wouldnt mind Mel B, Lily Allen. They need a young judge. Lily would be great IMO.

[stacey]

I can't see Sharon staying away for long, she always comes back but if she doesn't I can see Simon picking Amanda Holden but I think theres more chance of Sharon coming back

[Fom]

There are talks that Mel B is replacing her, says so on google news. Cant remember which news site it was.
Mel B would be a good idea I think, she is just as crazy as sharon.

[Bright-Eyes]

I would LOVE Mel B

[Callum]

Lily Allen would be great, she wouldn't hold back on giving an honest opinion. Paula Abdul would also be good.

[thisisme2008]

Mel B would be good, she is a massive personality like Sharon. Paula Abdul would be great too though i think.

[Jack_]

I hope Sharon comes back, it won't be the same.

I don't think they should of brought in Dannii in the first place, 3 judges was just perfect imo.

So I'm not sure they should get a replacement.

[Shaun]

You forgot Sinitta.

[Spike]

Sharon Osbourne said today on The Chris Moyles Show that they have asked Cheryl Cole and Mel B to be the new judge.

[Bright-Eyes]

I vote Mel B!

[Spike]

I would be happy with either Cheryl Cole and Mel B they would be brilliant, would prefer Mel B

[GiRTh]

I think Sharon will be back. I think any of those choices would be good but how about Randy Jackson.

[Spike]

Originally posted by GiRTh
I think Sharon will be back. I think any of those choices would be good but how about Randy Jackson.

It wouldn't surprise me if she comes back, she was very nice about the show even Dannii this morning so it could mean its just a publicity stunt.

Randy Jackson would be brilliant, he would be my first choice to be the new judge

[Dan_]

Originally posted by GiRTh
I think Sharon will be back. I think any of those choices would be good but how about Randy Jackson.

I think he should take over from Louis Walsh.

[andybigbro]

Kelly Osbourne would be great and hilarious as it was her mum that left
But i think Sharon will be back