[John.]

Here's my eye then...

Tell me what you all think!!

[BBkid]

Sorry, I hate it - also, can you not post thread titles in all capitals or put fan-made BB Designs in any forum except the BB Designs (fan-made) section.

[Hugo]

In a word - no.

[John.]

Originally posted by BBkid
Sorry, I hate it - also, can you not post thread titles in all capitals or put fan-made BB Designs in any forum except the BB Designs (fan-made) section.

Technically i didn't. the y in my is lowercase. and i'm not the only one who has posted fan made things in the this section.

So don't take it out on me!!

[John.]

Originally posted by HUGO
In a word - no.

Why not?? no offense but your comment was pretty pointless

[Sam!]

I think its pretty boring. I like the idea but it needs more thinking.

[BBkid]

Basically JohnD, what everyone is saying is it's not very good and the detail is poor and tacky. Yes you did do the title in all capitals (okay, maybe you did do a small y but it is messy and unneccessary) and yes I will take it out on you for posting it in this section. If you actually realised someone else was doing it wrong (elliebrew) then why do it wrong yourself?

[John.]

Originally posted by BBkid
Basically JohnD, what everyone is saying is it's not very good and the detail is poor and tacky. Yes you did do the title in all capitals (okay, maybe you did do a small y but it is messy and unneccessary) and yes I will take it out on you for posting it in this section. If you actually realised someone else was doing it wrong (elliebrew) then why do it wrong yourself?

Sorry for trying, gawd, sorry about the capitals, i did change them incase you didn't notice. get in a better mood, scrooge.

[Spike]

I like it, its different yet still looks like a BB eye
But the colours need a re-think, those 2 green bits just don't work for me and the shape of the top left of the eye needs work.

[MrGaryy]

More green, the two bits on their own, just looks like a copy of the single red shard from the BB9 one.

[John.]

Originally posted by Spike
I like it, its different yet still looks like a BB eye
But the colours need a re-think, those 2 green bits just don't work for me and the shape of the top left of the eye needs work.

thanks spike, i chose green because an eye has never had that colour before, but i wasn't keen.
what colour would you suggest?

[Sam!]

Originally posted by JohnD

thanks spike, i chose green because an eye has never had that colour before, but i wasn't keen.
what colour would you suggest?

Black.

[BBkid]

Sorry for trying, gawd, sorry about the capitals, i did change them incase you didn't notice. get in a better mood, scrooge. [/quote]

I'm in a good mood thanks but it gets annoying when people like you mess up the forum which gives the mods/admins more unneccessary work to do.

[Spike]

Originally posted by JohnD

thanks spike, i chose green because an eye has never had that colour before, but i wasn't keen.
what colour would you suggest?

I like the green but I just don't like it in the place its in at the moment. Try doing different sections and ideas with the green and see what looks best

[pinkmichk]

i quite like it but needs a bit more colour not sure what colour though i'd if i was doing it maybe do the colour so kinda looks like a barcode through the whole eye

[Billy]

Originally posted by BBkid
Sorry for trying, gawd, sorry about the capitals, i did change them incase you didn't notice. get in a better mood, scrooge.

I'm in a good mood thanks but it gets annoying when people like you mess up the forum which gives the mods/admins more unneccessary work to do. [/quote]

It also gets annoying when people like you don't **** about making changes to the forum which also gives the mods/admins more unecessary work to do, but we dont moan at you.

[LemonJam]

I really like the liney idea, but I don't think the green works.

Maybe try blue or purple?

[liam_bigbrother]

i actually really like the concept. The green would be ideal as it is one of the only colours there hasn't been but it needs more of it as the two stripes seems to similar to the bb9 eye. Also, it needs changing a little bit. I think it would look better if the lines curled round and intertwined between the other lines in some sort of green gradient.

Otherwise, realy good. i like it.

[Marsh.]

Crap! Start again

[LemonJam]

Originally posted by 08marsh
c**p! Start again

Note the title says "Constructive Criticism"

[Fom]

I think this forum needs a lesson in constructive criticism. I can teach you all like my students if you want and start teaching you about the 'Criticism Sandwich'. I WILL GO THERE!

I like the idea personally... its different.

[Glenn.]

I think its very Big Brothery. I think its good, sort of sets a style. Although not to sure on the colours, maybe if it had a consistant colour pattern, because at the minute its too BB9.

Edit:
After looking at your logo I took it upon myself to have a little muck around with it and I came up with this.




I think they work better with a little colour

[Glenn.]

Bump

[Annie]

BIT better with colour but still not amazing.

[Marsh.]

Originally posted by LemonJam

Note the title says "Constructive Criticism"

I know
'crap' means i didn't like it
'start again' is my advice
If he doesn't like it, then he shouldn't ask for it