[Gemmer-x]

Andy.

[xxweexstarxx]

Maria

[TopzTom]

Keeping voting either Brenda, Niki, Rowetta or Dionne.

My 1,000th post.

[Shaun]

I didn't want Maria...

[Billy]

Shaun Maria was one of the best :O

[Shaun]

OK, I've revised her and I'm happy with the 2 definites, but keep voting Brenda please! Dionne's only got 3 to choose from

[natjake2504]

Nicky - i think she has a great voice.

[Tom]

Niki or Brenda

[CassetteFinger]

Am i the only one who though dionne was crap. Her voice was so low it sounded like she sand out of her nose and she wasent likeable at all.

[Shaun]

Tom, you should have voted Brenda - Niki's obviously through

[Billy]

Shaun Dionne was MUCH beter than Brenda, IMO her first performance was better than any of Brendas

[Shaun]

No she wasn't - she had 3 terrible song choices, which she pulled off well. Whereas Brenda had tonnes of amazing performances.

[Billy]

Her first performance was one of the best choices :S

[Arneldo]

Brenda was soo much better then Dionne. Her voice was stronger, she has personality, likeability factor, she could vary in song selection & she had stage presence. She had a much better range in her voice then Dionne did. I liked Dionne, one of my fave ever contestants, but for me there is no contest between Brenda & Dionne. Brenda wins in my books, hands down.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Arneldo
Brenda was soo much better then Dionne. Her voice was stronger, she has personality, likeability factor, she could vary in song selection & she had stage presence. She had a much better range in her voice then Dionne did. I liked Dionne, one of my fave ever contestants, but for me there is no contest between Brenda & Dionne. Brenda wins in my books, hands down.

I agree. I luved Brenda, like I said, how she didn't win or come second I will never know. Lovely voice she has.

[dupin]

The poll is closed, and here are the results...

In 5th place, 4 people got 8.33% each, and they are ROWETTA, CHICO, ANDY and BEN

There's a tie for 3rd place, with two acts getting 11.11% each, meaning mentor Shaun will have to choose between BRENDA and DIONNE



In second, just being safe with 13.89% is ... MARIA



But your favourite 25+ is, with 22.22% of the vote....NIKI



So Niki, Maria, and either Brenda or Dionne ;; mentor Shaun will choose in this thread very shortly. Join us on Wednesday with the first live show, where the theme is "Best Past Performances"!

[Shaun]

Whilst I think Dionne would be an amazing finalist of mine, and she has a lot of talent, I have to go for Brenda - she's just outstanding.

[TopzTom]

Go, Brenda!

[Tom]

Brenda= The BEST X Factor has EVER had

How people can say Dionne is better is just beyond me. Dionne had a good voice, but she didn't have a personality. Brenda had an outstanding voice, and even Louis was crying when she left even though his act was in the final.

By far the most emotional exit they have ever done.

[Billy]

Tbh Louis cries at every Bottom 2

[XxShortyxX]

Yay Brenda

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy
Tbh Louis cries at every Bottom 2

Only when his own acts are in it

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7J6Jz67l9eM

Watch that and tell me that isn't emotional one bit and that she isn't as good as Dionne in that. That is her when upset.

[Billy]

Im not saying she isnt as good as Dionne, well I think i did, but didnt mena it. I just prefer Dionne