[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

I don't need to. The thread isn't based on it.

I simply asked you a question as you went from saying this lady was forced out of her home, to saying this lady followed her daughter who moved away and her daughter looks out for her.

Come back when you've decided which it is.

if her family lived in the area she wouldn't be moving, she is 90 fgs do you think she is doing it for laughs

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

Except it's not because you are simply trying to move the goalposts because you didn't expect anyone to have an answer for your hypothetical and now you are desperately backtracking.

But you didn't really answer my question, you just said something about it being good that the old is dying out and half of Japan is racist.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Cherie

if her family lived in the area she wouldn't be moving, she is 90 fgs do you think she is doing it for laughs

Nobody said that.

She's moving.... because her daughter is.... because her daughter helps her out.

I was asking where the "forced out" comes into play.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Nobody said that.

She's moving.... because her daughter is.... because her daughter helps her out.

I was asking where the "forced out" comes into play.

Technically she is being forced to move because none of her family are in the area to support her, not sure how many ways I can put that for you to get it.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Cherie

[/B]


Technically she is being forced to move because none of her family are in the area to support her, not sure how many ways I can put that for you to get it.

Right, so then that doesn't relate to the topic of people being forced out of areas due to culture clashes.

This 90yo had to move to follow her family, I got that at the start. I was asking if she was forced out due to a culture shift.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Alf

But you didn't really answer my question, you just said something about it being good that the old is dying out and half of Japan is racist.

I gave you a full answer, it's not my fault you are choosing to ignore parts of it because it suits you to do so.

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Dezzy

I have you a full answer, it's not my fault you are choosing to ignore parts of it because it suits you to do so.

To be fair to you, you did answer the second question, by saying yes, but only half of them.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Right, so then that doesn't relate to the topic of people being forced out of areas due to culture clashes.

This 90yo had to move to follow her family, I got that at the start. I was asking if she was forced out due to a culture shift.

Technically she was if that is why her family moved?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Cherie

[/B]

Technically she was if that is why her family moved?

Which was my question to begin with.

So her daughter was forced out then?

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Which was my question to begin with.

So her daughter was forced out then?

The programme is about white flight from the area as it is no longer multicultural, just one culture

we can put 2 and 2 together and get 10 if you want, I suggest you take time out to watch it

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Cherie

The programme is about white flight from the area as it is no longer multicultural, just one culture

we can put 2 and 2 together and get 10 if you want, I suggest you take time out to watch it

Doesn't sound appealing if it promises one thing but doesn't actually explain properly the circumstances of the people in it.

[Cherie]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Doesn't sound appealing if it promises one thing but doesn't actually explain properly the circumstances of the people in it.

Its quite an interesting watch tbf

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by Cherie

Its quite an interesting watch tbf

Yes, I'd agree. It was a very thought provoking programme.

I found I didnt have much sympathy for any of the cases. It was less dramatic than I thought, I was expecting stories of harassment and public disorder, but all the cases came across more thru choice than necessity.

[Tom4784]

Originally Posted by Alf

To be fair to you, you did answer the second question, by saying yes, but only half of them.

You asked a question thinking that no one would answer but you asked it about a culture you obviously don't know much about and so when someone that knows about the culture answered your question, you had to try and discount it because you didn't get the answer you wanted.

In future, don't ask a question if you don't want the answer.

[Alf]

The thing is my question doesn't have to be about Japan, it can be about, India, Brazil, Egypt, China ect

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Alf

The thing is my question doesn't have to be about Japan, it can be about, India, Brazil, Egypt, China ect

Yeah, but then you went on to say it's not about race, when your question was specifically about race. It was very confusing Alf.

[Alf]

Fook me, this place pisses me off at times.

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Yeah, but then you went on to say it's not about race, when your question was specifically about race. It was very confusing Alf.

If I said to you that sugar was sweet, you'd disagree with me. The only time you communicate with me is if you're disagreing with me.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Alf

If I said to you that sugar was sweet, you'd disagree with me. The only time you communicate with me is if you're disagreing with me.

Because I don't agree with anything you ever say. Do you want me to lie?

And deny it, but you did. You asked a question about white English people living abroad and then said it had nothing to do with race. I think you confused yourself tbh.

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Because I don't agree with anything you ever say. Do you want me to lie?

And deny it, but you did. You asked a question about white English people living abroad and then said it had nothing to do with race. I think you confused yourself tbh.

No I didn't ask that question, I didn't say English people, I said White people who speak English.

Let me put the question again, in a different way.

Let's say somebody from a majority White. English speaking country, eg England, USA, Australia, Canada Ect. They want to go on holiday to experience a different culture. They go to somewhere like, Egypt, India, Japan ect. When they get there, the country is majority White, English speaking immigrants from England, USA, Australia, Canada Ect.

Do you think that is a good thing, and not only a good thing but an essential thing for the good of that country?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Alf

No I didn't ask that question, I didn't say English people, I said White people who speak English.

Let me put the question again, in a different way.

Let's say somebody from a majority White. English speaking country, eg England, USA, Australia, Canada Ect. They want to go on holiday to experience a different culture. They go to somewhere like, Egypt, India, Japan ect. When they get there, the country is majority White, English speaking immigrants from England, USA, Australia, Canada Ect.

Do you think that is a good thing, and not only a good thing but an essential thing for the good of that country?

Do I think immigration is good for any country? Or do I think it's good if English speaking people are everywhere? Your question isn't clear.

FYI, you're still talking in terms of race and talking about whites Americans/white English people etc but whatever.

[Alf]

Originally Posted by Marsh.

Do I think immigration is good for any country? Or do I think it's good if English speaking people are everywhere? Your question isn't clear.

FYI, you're still talking in terms of race but whatever.

You think I'm taking in race, because you don't believe that White English speaking people have a culture.

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Alf

You think I'm taking in race, because you don't believe that White English speaking people have a culture.

No. You ARE talking race. You specify white Americans and white English people. You do realise there are black English people too?

Where did I say I don't believe White English speaking people have a culture?

Do you want to stop or continue tying yourself in knots?

[Alf]

If immigration is good for our country (which I'm not saying it isn't) Does that mean it's bad for the country they immagrated from?

Surely if we're taking all their best people, then their country suffers?

It's a form of colonialism is it not?

[Marsh.]

Originally Posted by Alf

If immigration is good for our country (which I'm not saying it isn't) Does that mean it's bad for the country they immagrated from?

Surely if we're taking all their best people, then their country suffers?

Don't worry Alf, Africa isn't going to run out of black people because a few live in White England.