[Billy]

Steph is auditoning for X Factor again

[GiRTh]

Now this is an interesting topic.

I hope she gets thru. I know there's a rule so that contestants can't audition multiple times but I think it only applies to acts who made the final 12.

Lets just hope Sharon doesn't get the girls this year.

[Billy]

Yeah it does, Im so happy at this as I think, if she gets a good mentor she
will definitely make it to the live shows. She's imrpoved so much from last year too

[xDramatick]

This is amaaazing.
wooo!

I hope she does well.

[KKBL]

she randomly added me on MSn about a month ago and told meb she wasnt but im glad shes changed her mind.

[Billy]

Same, Im so excited I hope she gets through

[Jack]

Was she the girl with braces? She was really good.

[Tom]

Originally posted by GiRTh
Now this is an interesting topic.

I hope she gets thru. I know there's a rule so that contestants can't audition multiple times but I think it only applies to acts who made the final 12.

Lets just hope Sharon doesn't get the girls this year.

I think it is just for the final 12 because I *think* in series 1 Chenai auditioned but Sharon never put her through at the judges homes (?) stage and in series 2 she made the live shows and was kicked out about 3 or 4 weeks in.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Mr.Glass
she randomly added me on MSn about a month ago and told meb she wasnt but Im glad shes changed her mind.

Same haha because I left her message on her site.

Yeah she had braces.

[xDramatick]

Originally posted by Mr.Glass
she randomly added me on MSn about a month ago and told meb she wasnt but Im glad shes changed her mind.

She randomly added me too, I haven't spoken to her yet though =O
lol.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom_

I think it is just for the final 12 because I *think* in series 1 Chenai auditioned but Sharon never put her through at the judges homes (?) stage and in series 2 she made the live shows and was kicked out about 3 or 4 weeks in.

Yeah Chenai got to judges houses and then got kicked out

[Shaun]

I don't think it'd be fair if she got a place in the final 12 or at the judges' houses this year, since she had a chance last year and it's be taking someone else's chance.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Shaun
I don't think it'd be fair if she got a place in the final 12 or at the judges' houses this year, since she had a chance last year and it's be taking someone else's chance.

A bit like Hope or Futureproof had their chance kidding i see where you are coming from

[GiRTh]

Originally posted by Shaun
I don't think it'd be fair if she got a place in the final 12 or at the judges' houses this year, since she had a chance last year and it's be taking someone else's chance.

But there's a rule so that she can do exactly that. In American Idol there have been quite a few contestants who had auditoned before. Carly Smithson in this years AI final 12 was just such a contestant. She auditoned in AI5.

[Shaun]

Originally posted by Billy21

A bit like Hope or Futureproof had their chance kidding i see where you are coming from

Well, they didn't audition as a group, and it was all obviously set up by the producers to do something different

And I know GiRTh, I'm saying there shouldn't be one.

Though I did like her last year, and if the quality of last year's contestants (Hope included) was anything to go by, I'd be happy for her to take someone else's place lmao.

[xDramatick]

Just watched Steph singing Bleeding Love on youtube

Youtube video

For a 16[?] year old.
That's incredible.

[hannahjane141627]

I loved her and really wanted her to get through

[Billy]

15 shes amazing

[Arneldo]

Oh god. No wonder she didnt make it to Live Shows. She isnt great. Even that little bully was better then her.

[Billy]

You said when Emily was in the live shows, that Stephanie woulda been better

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Billy21
You said when Emily was in the live shows, that Stephanie woulda been better

I'm goin by that cover of "Bleeding Love", im looking for her audition on youtube now. That cover is horrendus.

Although - if I remember. I think I said during the auditions that Emily was better then Steph.

[Billy]

Yeah you did but to be honest, that is kinda bad (bleeding love) I think her other songs are so much better= she is singing Im Alive for her audition, and she sounds great

[Tom]

Originally posted by Shaun

Well, they didn't audition as a group, and it was all obviously set up by the producers to do something different

And I know GiRTh, I'm saying there shouldn't be one.

Though I did like her last year, and if the quality of last year's contestants (Hope included) was anything to go by, I'd be happy for her to take someone else's place lmao.

Actually I agree with Billy and I'm not joking either. The Hope girls had their chance, and the lads in Futureproof did as well. They obviously weren't good enough but when it came down to it both groups stole a place in the live show that should have gone to groups who auditioned as groups. The same principle applies really.

Life auditioning to be on stage and to be a singer is full of rejection, so why should she not be allowed to try again and improve if she has already been rejected? It happens in TV programmes, some actors and actresses audition 6 or 7 times for the same show and for that number of different characters until they finally get in. Why should X Factor be any different?

[Arneldo]

Originally posted by Tom_

Actually I agree with Billy and I'm not joking either. The Hope girls had their chance, and the lads in Futureproof did as well. They obviously weren't good enough but when it came down to it both groups stole a place in the live show that should have gone to groups who auditioned as groups. The same principle applies really.

I agree.

Both Hope & FutureProof, had their chance and failed. They should not have been chosen over other groups. Plus, both groups were rubbish and only one person from both groups had any sign of talent (Phoebe, Hope).

[Billy]

oh no: disclaimer: i liked hope and didnt think they done anything wrong by getting through. (dont cyberslap me shaun)