[Noel]

I was thinking that it could be cool if The X Factor, instead of getting a new judge, have guest judges every week? I think it could make the show more interesting. What do you think? And, who would you like to see as a guest judge?

[Magic]

It would be good, but how would it work with them as Mentors?

[Billy]

It would be unfair on the category, as they would have a different mentor each week

[Noel]

Well, what they could do is combine the boys and girls and just have the 14-24s, which would make 3 categories, then the guest judge could spend maybe one day with all the categories and help them, then judge on the live shows. It sounds a bit complicated, but I think it could work. lol.

[Spike]

No I don't like the idea, I prefer how they do it now