[Tom]

I really enjoyed tonight, everyone was really strong and probably the strongest I've ever seen a live show to be. I think its proved the standard is definitely higher than ever before this year.

[Billy]

I think it was great, but the judges were WAY off.

[Z]

Yeah I thought so too! I thought Scott and Daniel were the weakest, but even they performed well. Can't wait to see who goes tonight!

[Tom]

Originally posted by Billy21
I think it was great, but the judges were WAY off.

Why?

(if that comes across as though I'm really disagreeing with you, its not I'm just curious thats all )

[Locke.]

I HATED it, worst X Factor show I've watched before tbh.

[XxShortyxX]

The judges were on drugs tonight, especially whe it came to Eoghan, anyway I really enjoyed tonight's show, the girls (Rachel and Ruth as well) were by far the bst tonight.

[Billy]

Originally posted by Tom

Why?

(if that comes across as though I'm really disagreeing with you, its not I'm just curious thats all )

Lmao.

Laura got called word class: She shouted her way through it
Eoghan is apparently the one to beat: LOL
Ruth was one of the best: if anyone should have got called word class, it was her.
Alexandra had been criticised every week for copycat, tonight Simon said she was original: It was a blatant Christina copycat lmao.
Rachel apparently deserves the break more than anyone: Because she's an ex junkie.
Daniel done a half decent performance: Louis and Simon still go on about how he wont sell records, rather than giving him praise he deserves.


(Well I thought so anyways)

I liked the performances tonight, but I just didn't get the comments towards the acts.

[Z]

I agree with all of your points Billy (apart from the Laura one)



Daniel deserves a break more than Rachel, I think!? She gave two bad performances and a fantastic one - he's given three OK performances in a row but has received little positive praise?

[XxShortyxX]

Rachel is miles better then Daniel, IMO. Tonght, she was amazing.

[Billy]

Originally posted by XxShortyxX
Rachel is miles better then Daniel, IMO. Tonght, she was amazing.

LOLOL.
Tonight fair enough, but the past 2 weeks Rachel has been awful even you can't deny that.
Daniel deserves more praise.

[Dan_]

It was certainly right up there, only a few weak performances with loads of really good ones.

[Red Moon]

Originally posted by Tom
I really enjoyed tonight, everyone was really strong and probably the strongest I've ever seen a live show to be. I think its proved the standard is definitely higher than ever before this year.

I don't look forward to Big Band week it just isn't my music style, but this year i thought the show was great.


And the girls were wonderful.

[XxShortyxX]

Originally posted by Billy21

LOLOL.
Tonight fair enough, but the past 2 weeks Rachel has been awful even you can't deny that.
Daniel deserves more praise.

I wouldn't say she was awful, the songs just weren't right for her.

[Tom]

I agree with your points Billy except the Laura one, I thought she was really good tonight but I think she peaked in the first week. I honestly can't see it with Eoghan, oh that reminds me, I've not done my weekly Eoghan bashing thread

[M X]

Yes, it was really good.