[MrGaryy]

For me it was Miley by far. She sang live and actually was really good and thats coming from who mostly dislikes her.

I'm A supporter of Britney most of the time and she was reall good on Star Academy and the Bambi's were okay but she did not deliver tonight.

[Matt08]

I thought Miley was better because she actually sang live.

[lily.]

Miley.

[30stone]

Miley was quality i thought her performance was better, though i was surprised as britney done ok though she did mime ...

Its real nice how they mention britney so much yet nothing for miley..

[Z]

I'd always rubbished Miley Cyrus as a crappy Disney singer without ever listening to her sing, but she has a very good voice, I was pleasantly surprised! I wish Britney had sung live, but I didn't expect her to - she did put on a good show though. Voted for Miley!

[Callum]

No question about it, Britney.

[Locke.]

Miley by far.

[Spike]

Surprisingly Miley even though I hate her

[Novo]

i never saw this

[ThisIsMarie]

Miley was really great but Britney won hands down.
(As if she wouldn't.)

It was plain to see.

Even though Miley's singing was better, Britney just has such an emense presence, she was completely enthralling almost.

[supernoodles!]

Britney was ****

[mizzy25]

hard to believe that mileys only 16