[Shaun]

Let's be honest, this is more important than TiBB members.


KEISHA MUTYA HEIDI YEAAAAH

[Z]

Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha.

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by Zee

Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha.

This. The original 3 were the best. Heidi is in 4th place though.

[Locke.]

Jade Ewen
Amelle B
Blonde one

[InOne]

Originally Posted by Shaun

Let's be honest, this is more important than TiBB members.


KEISHA MUTYA HEIDI YEAAAAH

^^

[Glenn.]

How many have their been?

[Niall]

The originals plz hehe.

[Z]

Siobhan > Mutya > Keisha > Heidi > Jade > Amelle

[Niall]

Originally Posted by Zee

Siobhan > Mutya > Keisha > Heidi > Jade > Amelle

Sibahn was

[Z]

Heidi is a really lovely person, but anyone could fill her shoes in that group. Siobhan, Mutya and Keisha are all very distinctive people with distinctive voices and the three of them together were just a brilliant combination.

[Beastie]

Ross likes the Sugababes.

But yeah probz the original 3 lyk.

I prefer their older songs.. that song that goes.. "a one way ticket to a something at situation??" or whatever it was! lol

[Callum]

Keisha, Heidi and Mutya

[Z]

I think Heidi, Jade and Amelle should only be performing songs that originally featured Heidi and Amelle; anything prior to that should be left in the past IMO. I'm willing to give them a chance as a group but there's very little news from them as to when to expect new music. Can't wait to hear Keisha's solo stuff!

['Conor]

Keisha Heidi Amelle !

I do love Jade though!

and i despise the original lineup.

[LaLaLand]

The originals were the best.

['Conor]

the original lineup was such a fail though?

['Conor]

i fell in love with the Sugababes with Freak Like me so i dont like anything before that

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by 'Conor

the original lineup was such a fail though?

I wouldn't say they were a fail. They came around in 1999/2000 and had a top 10 hit, which back then was a big deal as sales were a lot higher to achieve that, and they came about at a time when a lot of girl bands were around (and flopping) and at a time when stuff like 'Mr.Oizo', 'Sclub7' and 'Vengaboys' were number 1. 1999/200 were a strange, yet amusing years for music.

['Conor]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

I wouldn't say they were a fail. They came around in 1999 and had a top 10 hit, which back then was a big deal as sales were a lot higher to achieve that, and they came about at a time when a lot of girl bands were around (and flopping) and at a time when stuff like 'Mr.Oizo', 'Sclub7' and 'Vengaboys' were number 1. 1999 was a strange, yet amusing year for music.

Overload was amazing, and i do like Run For Cover, but thats it the other songs were flops, and the album is so dull.

['Conor]

i dont get how peoples favourite is the original line up they only had 1 album to judge on? and in my opinion is one of the worst sugababe albums

[Benjamin]

Originally Posted by 'Conor

i dont get how peoples favourite is the original line up they only had 1 album to judge on? and in my opinion is one of the worst sugababe albums

I loved that album. It's not OTT and very easy to listen to, whereas the other albums are very dancey and can only be listened to at the right moment. It also sold more in more countries than the last 2 Sugababe albums, so not a fail.

['Conor]

Originally Posted by ukturtle

I loved that album. It's not OTT and very easy to listen to, whereas the other albums are very dancey and can only be listened to at the right moment. It also sold more in more countries than the last 2 Sugababe albums, so not a fail.

well C&S was a fail lol, but i liked Sweet 7 and it is underrated, i just dont get how people can love the 1.0 Lineups sound so much, like 1.0 only had 12 songs whereas the next sugababes sound spanned across 6 other albums?

['Conor]

i don't think im making much sense but ah well

[Z]

I think it is kind of viewed with rose tinted spectacles but the praise is warranted nonetheless, when you consider how young they were when they first started working on that album, it really is an impressive album, as they contributed a lot to the song writing process. The songs were recorded in one take and when they sang live, they worked very well together. I think the line up worked because they were moody teenagers who weren't the best of friends, I think you need a little bit of resentment and competitive rivalry to produce the best possible result and unfortunately the rivalry got a little bit too much and Siobhan walked away. Siobhan's a perfectionist and Keisha's driven by success and sales; two very different types of egos with only one other person to mediate between the two and I guess when Heidi joined, there was nobody to really counter Keisha's ego. She's a very talented woman, but I think she must be a nightmare to work with, it's her way or the highway. I do think that 2.0 have a far superior back catalogue than 1.0, but they had the advantage of time on their side - when you look at the first album they released as a trio (with Heidi) it's not quite as good as 1.0 IMO.

-could go on for hours-

[cub]

Whoever sang Push The Button and Hole In Head. Them.