[starry]

Just put something on them to differentiate them. I don't like this making them one HM, I didn't like it in BB8 and I don't like it now.

[Jords]

Nah they are practically the same a John v Edward eviction would be naff.. although Id like to see how theyd cope seperated. Maybe if the other HMs had to choose 1 to save and 1 to evict it would work.

[CharlieO]

Channel 5 want them or Kerry to win as that will bring most press attention to the show. If they are together they are more likely to win.

[G1dds]

I thin it would be far more interesting if they treated them seperately - they are finding it far easier to attention seek & play up to the cameras when they are together all the time.

I also thought it was unfair on yesterdays show that one of plebward was allowed to just eat half that garlic thingy and yet both were allowed to the viewing - it should have only been one twit

[starry]

Originally Posted by Jords

Nah they are practically the same a John v Edward eviction would be naff.. although Id like to see how theyd cope seperated. Maybe if the other HMs had to choose 1 to save and 1 to evict it would work.

They are only the same as we just see their act all the time on the show, instead of looking at them as people. If they were separate they would then be forced to show them separately. They were just put in I think for their act for the very young fans they have, so it isn't Big Brother and is just The Jedward Show.

[Zippy]

if they were seperate their whole gimmick would be gone and theyd just be two useless individuals who need a tan.

[Kerry]

Impossible. Unless they made them both wear nametags (which they could switch anyway) who'd ever know which one they liked?

[starry]

Just have something to differentiate them as I said. Anyway Marcus always tells us who is in a room doesn't he?

...and John says 'ok' at the end of every sentence.

[joeysteele]

Not possible because the celebrities go in as who they are, Jedward are in as Jedward, make then John and Edward Grimes and then that is not the booked act/celebrity that went in.

It cannot be done. so will never happen.

[CaudleHalbard]

Yes they were booked as Jedward but it would have been good to see them split up for a couple of days with one going into a secret room or something and the other made to think their twin had been evicted.

Only trouble is the one left behind would want to walk, I suppose.

[Vicky.]

I would love to get to know them without the act they constantly put on when they are around each other.

Even if they were both still in together, but just dropped the preplanned bull**** that they have going on(to keep up the image, of course), and just be themselves :/

[InOne]

It's alright them being one HM but they are NEVER apart. And they wear the same clothes as eachother all the time, it's just ridiculous

[Mac Hiavellian]

On the one hand I'm glad they're counted as 1 because it means they won't just support each other and nominate the same people to show their brotherly alliance, but I'd still prefer them to be seperate because I didn't care for when Samanda became a single HM either. Twice there's been a wasted opportunity to evict 1 twun and see how the other copes, and twice BB UK's missed out on that trick BB Aus pulled off

[joeysteele]

I think they would have been assured that they remain Jedward totally for their time in the house, like Brian said when asked at the start of the series, were they likely to be split up, he said 'no they are one celebrity for the whole series'.
I have 2 sets of twins as cousins and they are together all the time and also dress always the same too, it's what most(not all) twins do.

I wouldn't like to see them split up anyway.

[Lewis.]

Would like to see one of them evicted and how the other one copes. John seems to be the dominant one so think it would be cool if he went. Can imagine that Edward would become a little lost and probably lose the act a bit. But C5 wont make half as much money in the final if Jedward aren't there together so can't see it happening.

[Lwize]

John and Edward are practically conjoined twins.
Separating them could kill the weaker one.

[fingers]

Just out of interest, as ONE HM did they come in with ONE suitcase and another point, what bleedin' size is it to hold a daily change of outer clothes?
Or is this another break with tradition and Ch5 has set aside a room for their wardrobe?

Is that the same room where their personal hairdresser visits them?

[joeysteele]

Sam and Amanda (Samanda) were in time classed as one housemate too, as for what's taken into the house,in the Celebrity one there was always more taken in by them.

Jedward are 'one' housemate because it is celebrity Big Brother, and 'Jedward' is the celebrity 'act' booked for it. They are not John Grimes and not Edward Grimes as to CBB, they are Jedward.

They are 'never' going to be split in the CBB house and neither should they be.

[Patricia4]

It's just ridiculous the way they dress alike all the time these boys wont cope on their own.

[CaudleHalbard]

Originally Posted by Patricia4

It's just ridiculous the way they dress alike all the time these boys wont cope on their own.

If you watched the 3-part TV documentary about Jedward, a few months back, you would see they don't dress the same when in the 'real world'.

Also they argue and bicker just like any siblings.

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by Patricia4

It's just ridiculous the way they dress alike all the time these boys wont cope on their own.

It's what twins do though, most of them do anyway. I have 2 sets of twins a scousins, they go to the same places together, do all the same things, dress exactly the same, I also know twins from my schooldays who are also like that too.

Twins have a really special bond, they are like one person.
Why on earth should Jedward not wear the same things if they want to, no one would get away with telling me how to dress.

[InOne]

Originally Posted by CaudleHalbard

If you watched the 3-part TV documentary about Jedward, a few months back, you would see they don't dress the same when in the 'real world'.

Also they argue and bicker just like any siblings.

I think I was washing my hair that day

[joeysteele]

Originally Posted by CaudleHalbard

If you watched the 3-part TV documentary about Jedward, a few months back, you would see they don't dress the same when in the 'real world'.

Also they argue and bicker just like any siblings.

Indeed, they did there, you are correct.
It was their more natural setting though,in the house they are as I said,Jedward,not the individuals.

Actually though yes, that series did cover a lot of ground as to them.You are spot on.

[starry]

Originally Posted by Lewis.

But C5 wont make half as much money in the final if Jedward aren't there together so can't see it happening.

I really don't see why they would make less money at all.


And on another point made I think Big Brother used to be the most real reality show, unfortunately now it just seems to be a show for some celebs to parade their act. Of course the celebs can get pampered and they probably have it in their contracts that they have to be together all the time and be counted as one HM. I think that is a bit weak of them though, it goes against the concept of Big Brother as a reality show.

[aiv]

Originally Posted by G1dds

I thin it would be far more interesting if they treated them seperately - they are finding it far easier to attention seek & play up to the cameras when they are together all the time.

I also thought it was unfair on yesterdays show that one of plebward was allowed to just eat half that garlic thingy and yet both were allowed to the viewing - it should have only been one twit

but John won the initial competition that was John v Edward and won a ticket, then Edward had to eat the kebab to get his ticket to join him, so that was pretty fair