[karl100589]

The grand trilogy of reality tv is now complete. Both Richard Hatch and Dr Will Kirby managed to suceed in their respective reality series with a reliance of wit, intelligence and strategy, now we can add Aaron to this list as well I feel.

And in the same way that Richard Hatch and Will Kirby's wins revolutionised the way people approached their reality tv shows can we now say the same thing about Aaron and BBUK?

[Roy Mars III]

[SoBig]

Richard Hatch, most overrated Survivor player ever. People only rate him that high because he was the first winner.

[Roy Mars III]

He is still one of the best. A true fan of the game. I would love to see him play in a new season when he gets out of jail and all.

[TheManWhoLaughs]

Will is cooler, Rich is smarter.

Aaron is a fab winner but he didn't win from a gameplan, he won because he was reaaaaaaal, as opposed to being faux-genuine like Jay and Alex.

[Yayita]

Russell Hanz is more of a legend than Richard Hatch IMO... even if he never won.

[TheManWhoLaughs]

Originally Posted by Yayita

Russell Hanz is more of a legend than Richard Hatch IMO... even if he never won.

Eww, he is as legendary as one of Jay's many turds.

Hantz was like Anton - a loser who just played to the camera would could never win.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by Yayita

Russell Hanz is more of a legend than Richard Hatch IMO... even if he never won.

[MaratSafinForever]

Richard is my favourite survivor ever!

[reece(:]

will kirby

[TheManWhoLaughs]

Originally Posted by reece(:

will kirby

So true

Aaron but not

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by TheManWhoLaughs

So true

Aaron but not

precisely

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III

He is still one of the best. A true fan of the game. I would love to see him play in a new season when he gets out of jail and all.

I like Richard, but I completely disagree. On his season, he was the only one that was playing the game. No one back then even wanted to be part of an alliance. So he ends up looking better than he really was. What did he do that was so impressive, walk around naked and catch fish?

Pavarotti
Russell Hantz
Boston Rob
Robb C.
Cirie
Todd
Brian
Tom
Earl
Yul

are all better players and the list is even longer than that.

Originally Posted by Yayita

Russell Hanz is more of a legend than Richard Hatch IMO... even if he never won.

Russell is the better player and its not even close, but Hatch is the bigger legend because he was the first winner.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by reece(:

will kirby

best reality show contestant ever.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by SoBig

I like Richard, but I completely disagree. On his season, he was the only one that was playing the game. No one back then even wanted to be part of an alliance. So he ends up looking better than he really was. What did he do that was so impressive, walk around naked and catch fish?

True and that's one of the reasons I would like to see him play again. On the first All Stars a lot of his tribe wanted him out just because he the was 'the godfather of the game' or whatever. I think if he played now, he wouldn't deal with that so much and we would get a much better look at how good of a player he can be.

[TheManWhoLaughs]

Originally Posted by SoBig

Pavarotti

Not even the best of the 3 Tenors

Will > Yul/Earl/RobC/other good players, because he was actually a great player and entertaining as well

[swinearefine]

Sandra Diaz Twine > all

But yeah, those three did change the way their respective shows were seen I think. But I hate Will and he's overrated as a person.

[swinearefine]

Sandra Diaz Twine > all

But yeah, those three did change the way their respective shows were seen I think. But I hate Will and he's overrated as a person.

[TheManWhoLaughs]

Originally Posted by swinearefine

Sandra Diaz Twine > all

But yeah, those three did change the way their respective shows were seen I think. But I hate Will and he's overrated as a person.

Sandra is the best player ever

But Will is more entertaining - he could actually win a UK BB based on vote-to-save, Sandra would leave early because any women who aren't vapid bimbos leave early in this country (Courtney > Sandra based on entertainment tho)

[alex_front2]

Aaron is the first intelligent winner of BB. BB4 winner Cameron wasn't intelligent he was just not thick and had help from the production crew pushing him to win ie going to Africa.

[Cromwell1900]

Originally Posted by karl100589

The grand trilogy of reality tv is now complete. Both Richard Hatch and Dr Will Kirby managed to suceed in their respective reality series with a reliance of wit, intelligence and strategy, now we can add Aaron to this list as well I feel.

And in the same way that Richard Hatch and Will Kirby's wins revolutionised the way people approached their reality tv shows can we now say the same thing about Aaron and BBUK?

As a Aaron opposer, congrat's to you. Aaron has been a legendary winner, and the first UK winner to actually win via a better strategy than his opposition.

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by Roy Mars III

True and that's one of the reasons I would like to see him play again. On the first All Stars a lot of his tribe wanted him out just because he the was 'the godfather of the game' or whatever. I think if he played now, he wouldn't deal with that so much and we would get a much better look at how good of a player he can be.

I'm sure he'll be on Survivor again. Jeff really wants him to be on an up coming season. He was suppose to be on Heroes Vs Villains, but couldn't because he wasn't allowed to leave the US.

He also played terribly on All Stars. He had no type of leadership role on his tribe. Lex and Colby had full control of the tribe. He had no idea of what was going on. He thought that he was never going to be voted out, because well he is Richard Hatch. His entire strategy was to walk around naked 99% of the time and try to be the provider by catching fish every other day. Turns out he wasn't even the best Fisherman on his team, Lex was.

On his season, all he did was form a 4 persons alliance. Thats it! The second best player that season was Sue Hawk. Who literally is one of the worst Survivor players ever.

Hatch is nothing special. He only gets this hype, because he was the first winner.

[SoBig]

Originally Posted by swinearefine

Sandra Diaz Twine > all

But yeah, those three did change the way their respective shows were seen I think. But I hate Will and he's overrated as a person.

Originally Posted by TheManWhoLaughs

Sandra is the best player ever

But Will is more entertaining - he could actually win a UK BB based on vote-to-save, Sandra would leave early because any women who aren't vapid bimbos leave early in this country (Courtney > Sandra based on entertainment tho)

SMH

Sandra is the best player ever? lmao

She is basically the Survivor version of Jordan from BB US.

Sandra is not even the best female Survivor player. Cirie probably has the best argument. Easily one of the best manipulators and strategist ever. Dominated 2 seasons from the start to finish. Would of won Panama is she knew how to make a fire and would of definitely won Fans vs Favorites if it wasn't for the final twist where they changed it from a final 3 to a final 2. In Heroes vs. Villains it took an Idol to get her out.

Sandra doesn't control her own fate and lucked into getting in to the finals 2 times against people who the jury hated. Wasn't even the best player in her season, Fairplay was better. In HvV Pavarotti and Russell were clearly better.

[Roy Mars III]

Originally Posted by SoBig

SMH

Sandra is the best player ever? lmao

She is basically the Survivor version of Jordan from BB US.

Sandra is not even the best female Survivor player. Cirie probably has the best argument. Easily one of the best manipulators and strategist ever. Dominated 2 seasons from the start to finish. Would of won Panama is she knew how to make a fire and would of definitely won Fans vs Favorites if it wasn't for the final twist where they changed it from a final 3 to a final 2. In Heroes vs. Villains it took an Idol to get her out.

Sandra doesn't control her own fate and lucked into getting in to the finals 2 times against people who the jury hated. Wasn't even the best player in her season, Fairplay was better. In HvV Pavarotti and Russell were clearly better.

This whole post is amazing. I agree with you 100% here.

[swinearefine]

Originally Posted by SoBig

SMH

Sandra is the best player ever? lmao

She is basically the Survivor version of Jordan from BB US.

Sandra is not even the best female Survivor player. Cirie probably has the best argument. Easily one of the best manipulators and strategist ever. Dominated 2 seasons from the start to finish. Would of won Panama is she knew how to make a fire and would of definitely won Fans vs Favorites if it wasn't for the final twist where they changed it from a final 3 to a final 2. In Heroes vs. Villains it took an Idol to get her out.

Sandra doesn't control her own fate and lucked into getting in to the finals 2 times against people who the jury hated. Wasn't even the best player in her season, Fairplay was better. In HvV Pavarotti and Russell were clearly better.

If Sandra is so bad, why did she win twice? I thought the goal of the game was to win, not dominate...