[stacey]

i really didnt like bens second performance tonight but the judges seemed to think it was amazing is it just me not liking it or does others agree with me

[Jay]

I thought it was good, hate it or love it he did well without music.

[BigSister]

no m,y mum siad same thing Stacey. I wasnt too keen but i loved his first 1

[andybigbro]

He was Rubbish

[stacey]

yeah i liked his first one it was just his second one that i wasnt a fan of

[Jay]

Originally posted by andybigbro
He was Rubbish

Rubbish? you try singing without music.

[BigSister]

I just didnt like the chior Jay i liked him singing acapella though

[stacey]

Originally posted by Jay

Rubbish? you try singing without music.

i tried that once

[BigSister]

I just didnt like the chior Jay i liked him singing acapella though

[Arneldo]

He was Amazing! Very brave singing a Queen song.

[Chrizzle]

I really disliked the arrangement and the performance as a whole.

BUT he gets the points for pulling it off.

[Crystal-Rose]

it was rubbish! i only listened to the first bit then didnt pay much attention lol!

[Dan_]

Originally posted by andybigbro
He was Rubbish

Being rubbish constitutes being out of tune, he wasn't

[Jay]

Originally posted by BB fernzy

Being rubbish constitutes being out of tune, he wasn't

Exactly and it was a brave performance to do.

[Siouxsie]

Originally posted by Jay
I thought it was good, hate it or love it he did well without music.

ditto

[x-heather-x]

I do like Ben but I thought he was absolute rubbish tonight. Well his forst song was good. But what was Somebody to Love about????
First off, i think teh should chose the more rocky performance with guitars and drums like Queen did. Instead the opted for the choir. I couldnt hear Ben at all over the noise of the gospel choir. I think Ben is far too good a singer to have all that help. He would have been amazing with himself a microphone and an electric guitar.

[Mike]

First performance was great as usual but the second one was pretty poor for him, still though he deserves to reach the final IMO simply because he has remained consistant.

[Bells]

Yeah, I was wondering, "What on earth's that about?"
But he was attempting to be different and take a risk, and he was singing without music after all.
Although I didn't like it, he's still proven he's a good singer.

[sol]

I thought his second performance was great, especially as he had no backing music.

[andybigbro]

Originally posted by BB fernzy

Being rubbish constitutes being out of tune, he wasn't

People have different opinions

Deal with it!

[Dan_]

Originally posted by andybigbro

People have different opinions

Deal with it!

I could deal with you saying you don't like his style of singing or the arrangement of that song but he was in tune the whole way through so he's not rubbish

[Sophii3x]

I didnt like it

[stoney12]

It did'nt work for me.Over ambitious and not really a good performance.

[Jay]

I thought his second performance was better then his first, he had no music and he was in tune all the way threw.

[Siouxsie]

was very brave to do that