[Z]

Paloma Faith would be good, she's a good personality, works well in front of audiences and would be different enough from Cheryl Cole to justify her presence on the panel. The more I think about it the more sense it makes, and it would give her music the platform it deserves.

[Black Dagger]

Yes out of all the names, Paloma is my real want now. But I'd take Fergie too. I just want them to reveal it now, I swear the proper auditions are in late May, so they can't be far from a reveal.

[reece(:]

no Paloma please, don't even know the flop ass bitch

get Fergie

[Z]

Paloma's funny, I don't feel like Fergie would add anything that Cheryl doesn't currently offer. Fergie's not even really doing anything right now and hasn't been for years, I get the impression the other Peas are just waiting for them to get back together.

[Jordan.]

Legend Kesha Rose's name looking out of place in the title with flops like Mel B and Laura Whitmore

[Strictly Jake]

I'd like Ashley Roberts she really has nothing going on now she needs to promote her career she has a great personality and is gorgeous. Yeah she isn't exactly a big name but this could be really good for her!

[Pete.]

mel b a flop

[Strictly Jake]

Yeah when Mel b was a guest judge a couple of years ago she was no fun at all. She would get so boring! I think Paloma faith would be better on the voice

[Pete.]

Queen Melaine has her experience tho :/

[Jack.]

Paloma faith denies X factor rumours

http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the...s-rumours.html

[Strictly Jake]

Originally Posted by Petemitch

Queen Melaine has her experience tho :/

Yeah but Victoria beckham has same amount doesn't mean she would be good. Actually did she do american idol once?

[Sophiee]

Originally Posted by ShakeyJake10

Yeah but Victoria beckham has same amount doesn't mean she would be good. Actually did she do american idol once?

I think mel b was a judge on america's got talent.

[reece(:]

Originally Posted by ShakeyJake10

Yeah but Victoria beckham has same amount doesn't mean she would be good. Actually did she do american idol once?

I hope to god that this isn't true

[Jack.]

Mel b was also a judge on Australia X factor and is currently a coach on the voice kids in Oz

[Strictly Jake]

Yeah Mel b has judged a few things. I was on about Victoria beckham. She once judged american idol and she was worse than Britney was on X factor us haha. Simon once wanted Victoria for X factor. I swear if she ever does get picked as a judge I wouldn't watch it again!

[Pete.]

britney slayed the X factor

[Jordan.]

All the spice girls are dusty has beens, none of them as a judge ty

[Kate!]

Victoria's never been a judge on Idol that I know of?

[Kate!]

Now Melanie C would be an excellent judge.

[Strictly Jake]

Originally Posted by Katherine.

Victoria's never been a judge on Idol that I know of?

She did a stint as a guest judge on the 9th season auditions but she was awful

[Jack.]

Looks like it's going to be mel b


http://tellymix.co.uk/reality-tv/the...lion-deal.html

[Tom4784]

I wouldn't mind Mel, she was quite good during her guest stint a few years back.

[Jack.]

Yeah at least mel has got personality. I would rather have mel over someone like Rita Ora

[Strictly Jake]

Please not Mel b!!! I reckon Alesha Dixon or Ashley Roberts would be a good call! And if Alesha does end up as an X factor judge then Ashley Roberts or Michelle Keegan would make good replacements on BGT mmmm haha

[Jack.]

There's a rumour going around that this is going be the panel this year.

Tinie(Tempah)-Mel B-Cheryl-Simon