[andybigbro]

If you have seen the documentary/ read up on his case. What is your view?

Vote in the poll.

[Glenn.]

I'm halfway through and I think he's innocent. Too much corruption

[GiRTh]

I cant decide.

[andybigbro]

Originally Posted by GiRTh

I cant decide.

Added an option for you

[Drew.]

Free Brendan

[GiRTh]

Originally Posted by andybigbro

Added an option for you

Thanks

[Ninastar]

I'm not sure. I'm halfway through the series and I think yes, the cops definitely interfered with everything, but then I also think that his past (the cat and those letters to his wife...) makes him seem not completely innocent.

I also don't understand why his nephew would make up those things about his uncle. But to counter that, surely there would have been blood all over the bed/house etc.

I'll post more once I've caught up/seen them all. Cause as of now, I don't have an answer

[Drew.]

Originally Posted by Ninastar

I'm not sure. I'm halfway through the series and I think yes, the cops definitely interfered with everything, but then I also think that his past (the cat and those letters to his wife...) makes him seem not completely innocent.

I also don't understand why his nephew would make up those things about his uncle. But to counter that, surely there would have been blood all over the bed/house etc.

I'll post more once I've caught up/seen them all. Cause as of now, I don't have an answer

This is a pretty strong theory that he and his dad were behind it and not Avery and Brendan so any distraction away from them would make a lot of sense.

[Ninastar]

Originally Posted by Drew.

This is a pretty strong theory that he and his dad were behind it and not Avery and Brendan so any distraction away from them would make a lot of sense.

that would make sense, I'll watch the rest of the eps now (before i fall asleep anyway)

[Ammi]

....hmmm I don't know, I keep leaning toward innocent but then read up on something online that wasn't shown in the series and start to think guilty because the series was very much geared up to innocent, following on from his 18yr wrongful conviction, so that's obviously where we're been led...I'm starting to wish that I'd had a chance to study the case without seeing Making of a Murderer first.....just so that I hadn't been given that slanted/type view...

[Ammi]

...I'm also starting to think that the whole police dept/forensic team where just possibly completely incompetent ...two serious crimes, with the first wrongful rape conviction as well and basically messing up with both and their incompetence started to look like conspiracy because they had to try to ensure his conviction, feeling for sure themselves that he was guilty...

[Ammi]

[Cal.]

Originally Posted by Ammi