[Lampfan]

Originally Posted by BB-Germany

Tbh even though it seems like they are all pretty similar, they actually are extremely different from each other and won for different reasons each.

James won because he is British and came across as a nice lad.
Scotty won because people hated Stephanie. Geordie Shore didn't hurt as well.
Jason won because people pitied him in a way, but also saw the moral winner in him. A typical BB-winner tbh.
And Bear won because all the others were either American or plain boring. Ricky was even for the Bear-haters too boring to vote for.

Summed up nicely (though I can't comment on James, didn't bother with that series when I saw Farrah Abraham's name)

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by Riley.

James was a nice guy, Scotty was decent in the house (he didn't deserve to win but he was okay) Jason is the best of the lot of them but Bear is worse than Helen Wood.

I totally agree with you there...

[_Tom_]

Jason was a great winner, the others are complete trash.

[Garfie]

In my opinion, although neither James or Scotty were my chosen winners, James was a decent winner whereas Scotty T was okay-ish.

Jason, to me, was boring and unforgettable, and Hughie was the housemate I enjoyed most and will always remember from that series - he was robbed! I didn't enjoy Bear as a housemate, and am disheartened by his win.

[Daniel R]

leave jason out of this

[Heaven = Winner]

Scotty T and Bear are diabolical.

James is severely underrated on here imo. He wasn't the /most/ entertaining, but he certainly held his own, especially compared to other winners.

[Mystic Mock]

James was awful and only won because of his looks.

Scotty T did nothing either.

Jason played the victim role and won off that.

And Bear played the obnoxious troll role from his Viacom show.

Basically I agree with Elliebrew to an extent.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Heaven = Winner

Scotty T and Bear are diabolical.

James is severely underrated on here imo. He wasn't the /most/ entertaining, but he certainly held his own, especially compared to other winners.

James should thank Austin and Farrah for giving him screentime.

[Mitchell]

It could've been worse, the last four winners could've been Austin Armacost, Stephanie Davis, Jackson and Marnie...

[bots]

appalling winners == not the op's chosen favourites

i think everyone feels that when their personal favourite misses out ...

I'm more concerned about the underlying purpose of the show now rather than who actually wins it ... as identified in other threads

[y.winter]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

I'm more concerned about the underlying purpose of the show now

Yep, this

[CaPPa]

Most of the recent winners have been pretty poor. Jordan only won because the viewers had a bit of conscience and didn't vote for the attention seeking Perez. This year they decided to vote for the attention seeker as there wasn't a Jordan to fall back on. Scotty T was a better person than he appears on Geordie Shore but a pretty meh winner. Jason deserved it though, because although he wasn't particularly entertaining he did have a hard journey.

[*mazedsalv**]

1. James
2. Jason




3. Bear
4. Scotty T