[Barbie]

on BBLB they were saying how the twins could release the christmas song they sing and it would go to number one.
do you think it will be a success? especially with X factor around

[BeckyBee]

No thanks - there is always enough crap out at Christmas without adding to it!

[Barbie]

im not sure if they will or not
i think if they did it would have a good chance of getting to number one and without X factor it probably would

[Loukas]

yeah why not

[Jackie]

Yes i think it will make no 1 ,if they released a single their songs are quite catchy.

[GlitterEyes]

Sadly I think they could go well...they look great and bring a smile to people.

[Shaun]

Oh God...that'd be terrible. But I think it'd unfortunately do well.

[supernoodles!]

lol why not,would be fun to see the video!

jingle bell ,jingle bell,jingle bell rock!

They have just ripped off mean girls though with their dance routine

[stacey]

i'm not sure, they would have a lot of support for it because of the amount of people liking them but i don't think it will be able to compete and beat the x factor winners single for christmas number one.

[Moses455]

This is a farce. The twins cannot sing, they are tone deaf. Surely this is proof positive the the pop industry is about making money as the twins are marketable, not about singing in tune or talent. I watched a clip from TOTP2 last night, and saw this incredibly talented performance of a song by John Miles called 'Music'. That was talent. He was an average looking guy, but he played piano, electric guitar and sung amazingly, and wrote the song. It is a cross between classical, a nice piano ballad and rock. THIS is talent.

Even if people like the twins, (I DESPISE them), this does not mean they should flood the market with their talentless voices.

Anyone who thinks they can sing in key when listening to 'A Whole new World', is quite simply, wrong. If I put them through an auto tuner, they still would sound wrong, as they aren't even a semi-tone out.

The music business is a pile of poo.

[supernoodles!]

if this did happen I dont the the twins would be claiming to be some sort of whitney and mariah,it would be for pure novelty value,not to be taken to seriously.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by supernoodles!
if this did happen I dont the the twins would be claiming to be some sort of whitney and mariah,it would be for pure novelty value,not to be taken to seriously.

Yes, and they receive lots MORE money for a load of talentless trash. I would approve, if they donated all the money they made (or the record company makes) to a charity.

[supernoodles!]

So what.they deserve the money they`d make for it,after all im sure it would take alot of time and effort so why shouldnt they be rewarded with cash ,just like anyone else would.If the cheeky girls can release an album (maybe 2,i dont actually keep track) then why not sam and amanda,i mean at least there likable!

[Moses455]

Originally posted by supernoodles!
So what.they deserve the money they`d make for it,after all Im sure it would take alot of time and effort so why shouldnt they be rewarded with cash ,just like anyone else would.If the cheeky girls can release an album (maybe 2,i dont actually keep track) then why not sam and amanda,i mean at least there likable!

I think the Cheeky girls are nonsense also.

You tell me they DESERVE the money they'd make?

1) They will win 100,000 from BB and you say they deserve MORE.
2) Time and effort?

Do you know ANYTHING about the recording studios nowadays. They could send 5 minutes recording their vocals and they are done. It is all auto-tuned.

They do not write music, cannot sing and have no talent.

I spend hours slogging songs in my recording studio, yet you are telling me that they DESERVE money for this?

They have no talent, so how can they DESERVE the money?

[bananarama]

As much as I like the twins I think a single would have to escape rather than be released...

[supernoodles!]

Yes i do think they deserve the money,why not?If Z list celebs like rebecca loos,bianca gascoine and peaches geldoff can make money for themselves off the back of hurting other people are using some one elses name then i dont see why two lovely,genuine,young girls like the twins do not deserve too

[CassetteFinger]

No x factor would go straight to number 1 you all know that it gets much more people watching x factor than big brother.

[supernoodles!]

I dont know why,i think x factor sucks,even though i get dreagged into it every year some how lol.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by supernoodles!
Yes i do think they deserve the money,why not?If Z list celebs like rebecca loos,bianca gascoine and peaches geldoff can make money for themselves off the back of hurting other people are using some one elses name then i dont see why two lovely,genuine,young girls like the twins do not deserve too

what a load of nonsense. Just because you think ppl are nice, doesn't mean they deserve money for releasing a single.
Where is the talent?

[supernoodles!]

look what im saying is if other people can release a single who have no talent why cant they!Its my opinion,respect it and accept it

[Moses455]

Originally posted by supernoodles!
look what Im saying is if other people can release a single who have no talent why cant they!Its my opinion,respect it and accept it

I do not accept your opinion. NOBODY who is talentless should release a single. I do not endorse The twins, the cheeky girls, the spice girls, or any talentless twaddle.
Your argument is hypocritical. 'Oh, I think loads of talentless stuff is released, so why not the twins?'
That's like saying 'oh there's loads of murderers how about one more?'

A person of true integrity would aim to rid the world of ALL talentless crap.

Your argument also suggests that ANYBODY who is 'nice' (I think the twins are the spawn of satan), should release a music single.
That makes a mockery of music, which should only be produced by talented people, not nice people. Shall we now have nice architects? Nice teachers? Nice politicians?
Let's forget about talent.

What a load of bollox.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by supernoodles!
I dont know why,i think x factor sucks,even though i get dreagged into it every year some how lol.

Please spell correctly:

Somehow not some how.

[James]

Respect other peoples' opinion (and the rules of the forum)... last chance.

[Tom4784]

Listen people I think it's best that Moses and Supernoodles agree to disagree. Everyone is entitled to an opinion so let's just accept it huh?

Now let's move on, I say that if they want to do a single then best of luck to them, the song probably wouldn't be that good but all the best to 'em I say. It wouldn't compete with X Factor but all the best to 'em.

[Moses455]

Originally posted by James
Respect other peoples' opinion (and the rules of the forum)... last chance.

This isn't school.