[Harry!]

[dupin]

Dannii!

[Chrizzle]

Simon, what a legend.

[XxShortyxX]

I luv Sharon, she just makes me laugh, and her laugh is so funny.

Simon is so funny though, with his comments.

[Billy]

Danii

[Retroman]

Simon's judging is clearly the best, as he is brutally honest most of the time.

However, he does tend to take pity on bad singers with horrible life stories and puts them through because he feels sorry for them...which I feel is just his way of making himself look good, and not something he would do off television.

The Xtra factor also shows a lot of him ignoring people outside of the judging room, constantly on his phone and being quite unsociable to some people too.

So that being said, it puts me off him a little.

But yea, on pure judging talent, I vote Simon =]

[Nicola]

Simon, I love him to bits and get all sorts of comments and ribbing from my family and friends cos I have this massive crush on him.

[BigSister]

Simon and Sharon Simon a bit more than sharon though

[Harry!]

Simon!

[Bells]

Has to be Simon. I feel that some bits are staged or over-exaggerated sometimes on the X Factor, so I don't let Simon's personal qualities on display affect my opinion of his judging. Some of his comments do have me laughing, but above all he makes a lot of sense in what he says.

He's by far the best judge.

[Shaun]

Simon

Who voted Louis? Haha, only joking.

[Jackie]

Sharon because she sometimes shows real emotions over the contestants.

[Dan_]

Easily Simon,he doesn't sugercoat things and he's in the right most of the time.

Danni seems a bit lifeless, Sharon's a bit too nice and not constructive enough with her critiques and Louis is just a daft sod most of the time.

[12bigbrother12]

Sharon

[Ruth*Star]

Sharons mine.