[Henry2014]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

A lot, I asked a simple question, is she a full blown SHE or still a HE, either answer my question or don't answer as that would be going off topic ,thank you and a Happy New Year to you and yours xxx

Interesting approach to gender there in terms of ‘he’ and ‘she’.

Genitalia is considered to relate to Sex rather than Gender. So nothing to do with pronouns or gender identity.

Maybe you’d do well to spend more time reading than writing posts on a big brother forum

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

A lot, I asked a simple question, is she a full blown SHE or still a HE, either answer my question or don't answer as that would be going off topic ,thank you and a Happy New Year to you and yours xxx

Depends how you define "he" and "she". Even if she has had the cut-and-fold, she'll still be biologically male, nothing will ever change that. So it's silly to use that as an indicator as to what to call her.

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Henry2014

Interesting approach to gender there in terms of ‘he’ and ‘she’.

Genitalia is considered to relate to Sex rather than Gender. So nothing to do with pronouns or gender identity.

Maybe you’d do well to spend more time reading than writing posts on a big brother forum

Well

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

Depends how you define "he" and "she". Even if she has had the cut-and-fold, she'll still be biologically male, nothing will ever change that. So it's silly to use that as an indicator as to what to call her.

That will go down like a lead balloon

[Fetch The Bolt Cutters]

Originally Posted by Jake.

Lol you’re such a gross human being

.

[Greg!]

Whether she still has a willy or not is irrel, she is a woman so that's how you address her. Simple!

[Shaun]

I generally find just calling someone by the pronouns they wish to be called by saves a lot of argument and hassle Wondering the ins and outs of their surgical history is a bit intrusive and something one would only really share with close friends and family (or the nation if they're fame-hungry ), not really something to just demand full knowledge of up-front as if they're a sex offender.

[chuff me dizzy]

And just to confirm to the bigots on here, i really like India ,and find her great fun on BBBOTS ,i was asking a simple question ,which once the "gang" had pounced on to my question they turned it into "transphobia" ( I will have to remember that new phobia) .......... ( or maybe not )

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Whether she still has a willy or not is irrel, she is a woman so that's how you address her. Simple!

Of course she's not a woman if she's got a willy ...Sweet Jesus !!!!!!

[Greg!]

Leave Chuff alone she was just interested!

[Greg!]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Of course she's not a woman if she's got a willy ...Sweet Jesus !!!!!!

Ok I take it back, you are trash. Ban her!

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Ok I take it back, you are trash. Ban her!

Nutter

[Kazanne]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

All Chuff is asking is if she has transitioned and had a medical procedure, but in a polite way. WTF is offensive about that. I don't have a clue else I would have answered, but its a pretty simple question

Yes my thoughts too,absolutely nothing wrong with anyone asking,why people get so offended Christ knows, Hopefully IF it's an all female start I would hope he is now a she.It's not bigoted it's curiousity.

[Cal.]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Ok I take it back, you are trash. Ban her!

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by Greg!

Ok I take it back, you are trash. Ban her!

[Oliver_W]

Originally Posted by Kazanne

Hopefully IF it's an all female start I would hope he is now a she.It's not bigoted it's curiousity.

She is a she whether or not she's had it done.

[smudgie]

She is a woman then.
I admit to being a bit ignorant on the whole trans subject, I don't know when someone officially changes their status, but if someone asked me to specifically be called by a certain gender then I am happy to oblige.
I don't think it's transphobic to discuss it, the more we hear about it the better, makes it more understandable to us that are genuinely clueless.

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by Oliver_W

She is a she whether or not she's had it done.

Of course she's not, if she's got all her original bits still in place she's a man ! Sweet God, how can you make it sink in with folk

[Withano]

Originally Posted by Henry2014

Interesting approach to gender there in terms of ‘he’ and ‘she’.

Genitalia is considered to relate to Sex rather than Gender. So nothing to do with pronouns or gender identity.

Maybe you’d do well to spend more time reading than writing posts on a big brother forum

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Of course she's not, if she's got all her original bits still in place she's a man ! Sweet God, how can you make it sink in with folk

Are you blind or just ignorant?

Originally Posted by Henry2014

Interesting approach to gender there in terms of ‘he’ and ‘she’.

Genitalia is considered to relate to Sex rather than Gender. So nothing to do with pronouns or gender identity.

Maybe you’d do well to spend more time reading than writing posts on a big brother forum

I’m guessing it’s the latter

[Withano]

It did start off as just an intrusive question to be fair to Chuff (genuinely wrote Trump there by accident lol), but these three pages of posts just show ignorance, and yes transphobia. Perhaps you should do some reading up on the basics before tonights show, Chuff.

[rusticgal]

Originally Posted by bitontheslide

All Chuff is asking is if she has transitioned and had a medical procedure, but in a polite way. WTF is offensive about that. I don't have a clue else I would have answered, but its a pretty simple question

Her question was straight and to the point....not nit picking words to tiptoe round over sensitive people who are too quick to point the finger and name call at the drop of a hat....the question was simple..straight talking ffs.

[chuff me dizzy]

Originally Posted by rusticgal

Her question was straight and to the point....not nit picking words to tiptoe round over sensitive people who are too quick to point the finger and name call at the drop of a hat....the question was simple..straight talking ffs.

A straight question that required a "Yes" or "No" answer,but not with this lot

[Smithy]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

A straight question that required a "Yes" or "No" answer,but not with this lot

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

I need to get something right in my head before the launch ,does India sit down or stand up to pee? has she had the full shebang or is she still male therefore making her still a male ?

Yes!

[Lostie!]

Originally Posted by chuff me dizzy

Lets forget the loo,has he still got his tackle in place ?

Alright George Khan