Quote:
Originally posted by VickyJ
Quote:
Originally posted by ElProximo
Quote:
Originally posted by VickyJ
Quote:
Originally posted by ElProximo
Quote:
Originally posted by Entervoice
Quote:
Originally posted by tremault
do some more research. panic attacks are different for different people.
|
True
|
False.
|
^^Bollox
They are different for different people, and even for the same person they can have varying degrees of intensity.
|
In a previous post I compared this to saying "Urination is different for different people'.
Well wonderful!
You would probably add to that "Bollox. there is also different degrees of urination intensity'.
Well researched and well understood:
Panic Response, similar to many other human physiological responses like 'Laughing' or 'Yawning' or 'cold temperature response' are UNIVERSAL for all living human beings.
Yes.
This is not a 'who knows' debate but you only need to:
- be subject to panic attacks (which are not really 'attacks') for a decade,
- spend years studying this physiological miracle
- meet and eventually counsel hundreds of people who experienced these.
Again, you can go ahead and say 'well its different for everyone',
but,
what you have said is as helpful as saying 'digesting food is different for everyone,
or
"well laughing is different for everyone"
or
"well how the body responds to cold temperatures is different for everyone".
Well wonderful. what a great insight.
Meanwhile - all of those things are most definitely going to follow the same principles in all humans.
They are not 'randomly sorted' or to be believed that one person might digest solids in their kidney,
while another squirts insulin on his birthday,
yet another might urinate gasses.
One of THE most fascinating things a new person will encounter the first time they hear detailed testimonies from others in group:
How not only are the physiological symptoms largely the same but even how SPECIFIC thoughts, sometimes even word-for-word the self-talk is between them and others and how exactly identical so many 'interpretations' are between different people.
Which is massively helpful as (for example) they believed that nobody else ever looked at a kitchen knife on the counter and had a scary thought "what if I picked that up and cut myself",
yet,
20 other 'panic attack sufferers' had word-for-word identical thoughts.
Anyways.. I wish you would stop posting deliberately stupid antagonisms at me.
I know you wont but I can dream cant I?
|
I cant be bothered to read another one of your ridiculously long and usually bullshit filled posts, so answer me this one question. If they are not different for different people, how come some people dont even realise they take them, until afterwards when they are diagnosed, because they are so mild, and others feel like they are having a heart attack? How come some people merely get breathing problems whilst others visibly suffocate? How come some people vomit during, and others dont? Come on mr expert...lets hear you contradict my partners GP 
|
Following a lengthy post the other day "analysing" Marcus' relationship with his "abusive father" I did ask ElProximo for information regarding his competence and professional qualifications.
Unfortunately he has not yet provided it.
Normally I would not ask but I have noticed that ElProximo often posts in a manner suggesting he has a certain professional competence in psychology, greater than the general observations of a layman, so I think it is worth clarifying.
12-08-2009, 08:54 AM
Threaded Mode