[AndyJK]

Originally posted by LEE
I agree with you that Susanne is one of the most talented contstants left in there and I hope you are wrong and she doesn't go this weekend.

As to her singing songs that are unsuitable for her voice, she doesn't really have much choice in the matter with Pop Idols format of different themes every week. It does make good television, but it isn't very fair on the performers. I know people will say that they should have the ability to perform different styles of music equally well, but that isn't necessarily true - I mean look at Nora Jones, how would she have done in the disco week, and very few deny her star quality.

I hope I'm wrong LEE, but last Saturday when it was widely acknowledged Susanne performed better than the others she ended up finishing in the bottom two. And the different themes which demonstrate the versitility of the contestants voices have showed for several weeks Susanne struggling to maintain any consistency. She's still in there because she does have a great voice, personality and looks good.

One positive thing I will say is that Susanne appeared more confident on last Saturday's show, let's hope she can build on that.

I'm more or less certain the final will be between Chris and Sam now.