[robb]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Take notice of this girl's wise words.

She knows, she knows.

Well I say remember Alexander Burke, and how she was overshadowed by the hype surrounding Diana and Rachael for the first half of the live show, though outsinging them week after week. Class lasts, and she came through and won. Who knows how Katie or Cher will sit with the public in a few weeks. What is certain is that they were outclassed by Rebecca, Gamu AND Tracey at Cheryl's house. She had made her mind up before they sang.

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by robb

What is certain is that they were outclassed by Rebecca, Gamu AND Tracey at Cheryl's house. She had made her mind up before they sang.

Well I know that. Theyre at the house to be given the verdict really. The performance bit is just for the show. The decisions are made from the auditions.

So how they perform at the house is not actually relevent. Something all the uproarers dont seem to get. Who cares if you mess up in front of a few people? Its on a stage with an audience that matters.

And even if they mess up on the actual main show then its all good TV anyways. Its drama.

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Well I know that. Theyre at the house to be given the verdict really. The performance bit is just for the show. The decisions are made from the auditions.

So how they perform at the house is not actually relevent. Something all the uproarers dont seem to get. Who cares if you mess up in front of a few people? Its on a stage with an audience that matters.

And even if they mess up on the actual main show then its all good TV anyways. Its drama.

why would you want somebody to be mocked by millions of people?

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by jedward fever

why would you want somebody to be mocked by millions of people?

Mocked? They usually get sympathy and more votes!

[Mystic Mock]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Mocked? They usually get sympathy and more votes!

yeah 9 to 10% of the vote at most.

[robb]

Originally Posted by Zippy

Well I know that. Theyre at the house to be given the verdict really. The performance bit is just for the show. The decisions are made from the auditions.

So how they perform at the house is not actually relevent. Something all the uproarers dont seem to get. Who cares if you mess up in front of a few people? Its on a stage with an audience that matters.

And even if they mess up on the actual main show then its all good TV anyways. Its drama.

What may be slightly relevant is which judge gets which category. Cheryl Cole has never had the groups or the oldies. And when Cher came along you just KNEW that she was gonna end up with Cheryl. (BTW....didn't Katie mess up at the auditions as well??).

[Zippy]

Originally Posted by robb

What may be slightly relevant is which judge gets which category. Cheryl Cole has never had the groups or the oldies. And when Cher came along you just KNEW that she was gonna end up with Cheryl. (BTW....didn't Katie mess up at the auditions as well??).

Well I think Simon and Louis are essentially businessmen so I dont think theyre as emotionally involved as the girls. So they are more happy to take the weaker categories and fight against the odds. Its probably a challenge for them. Plus Louis is essentially a group manager so he's very used to dealing with those dynamics.

For the girls dealing with so many people in groups may be a bit much possibly. And the older acts less willing to take their advice. But essentially I think they are indulged a little and given the younger acts they can relate to more. Makes it more enjoyable for them and Im sure Simon and the producers want to keep them happy.